FAILURE MAP
← Case archive

FA-84911 / Fantasy sports scoring / Open access

Extra points fall through into field goal scoring · case 01

Each made PAT also scores as a 32-yard field goal.

Verified by executionVariant 1 · 7 checks per implementationDownload source bundle ↓JSON ↗

ROOT CAUSE

The PAT branch does not skip the field-goal logic after scoring.

VERIFIED REPAIR

Continue to the next kick after scoring any PAT.

Unsuccessful approach: Skipping only made PATs lets missed PATs also collect a short-miss field-goal penalty.

Case contract

Score a kicker. Kick distance is the line-of-scrimmage yardline plus 17 (10 yards of end zone and a 7-yard hold). Made FG: <=39 yards 3, 40-49 4, 50+ 5. Missed FG: <=39 -2, 40-49 -1, 50+ 0. Blocked FG and blocked PAT score 0. PAT made +1, missed -1. Return [points, longest made FG distance or 0].

Why this case matters

Kicker distance bands and miss penalties are a classic source of scoring disputes.

1 / The failure

Exit 1
"""Failure Map reference implementation. Python standard library only."""
import json

N = 1
observations = []
def solve(kicks):
    pts = 0
    longest = 0
    for k in kicks:
        if k['type'] == 'pat':
            if k['result'] == 'made':
                pts += 1
            elif k['result'] == 'missed':
                pts -= 1
        dist = k['yardline'] + 17
        if k['result'] == 'made':
            pts += 3 if dist <= 39 else 4 if dist <= 49 else 5
            longest = max(longest, dist)
        elif k['result'] == 'missed':
            pts += -2 if dist <= 39 else -1 if dist <= 49 else 0
    return [pts, longest]
def check(label, actual, expected):
    observations.append({"check": label, "actual": actual, "expected": expected, "passed": actual == expected})
fixtures = [[('regression: extra point fallthrough',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33}, {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}]],
   [4, 50]),
  ('partial repair probe: extra point fallthrough',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33}, {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 32}]],
   [8, 50]),
  ('second regression',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 36}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}, {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22}]],
   [7, 53]),
  ('normal control 1',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 28}, {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 32},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 43}]],
   [8, 60]),
  ('normal control 2', [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33}]], [5, 50]),
  ('normal control 3',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22}, {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 4}, {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22}]],
   [6, 39]),
  ('normal control 4',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 32}, {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33},
     {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 2}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22},
     {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 34}]],
   [12, 51])],
 [('regression: extra point fallthrough',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 23}, {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 2},
     {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}, {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 32},
     {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}]],
   [2, 40]),
  ('partial repair probe: extra point fallthrough',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 23}, {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22}]],
   [6, 40]),
  ('second regression',
   [[{'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 25}, {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 32},
     {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22}]],
   [0, 0]),
  ('normal control 1',
   [[{'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22},
     {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 23}]],
   [4, 40]),
  ('normal control 2',
   [[{'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 6}, {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22}]],
   [-1, 39]),
  ('normal control 3', [[{'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 34}]], [0, 0]),
  ('normal control 4', [[{'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22}]], [-2, 0])],
 [('regression: extra point fallthrough',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}]],
   [2, 0]),
  ('partial repair probe: extra point fallthrough',
   [[{'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 32}, {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22}]],
   [2, 39]),
  ('second regression',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 23}, {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 34},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 23}, {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 34}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}]],
   [14, 51]),
  ('normal control 1',
   [[{'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22},
     {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 23}]],
   [-2, 0]),
  ('normal control 2', [[{'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33}]], [0, 0]),
  ('normal control 3',
   [[{'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 11},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33}, {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 34}]],
   [13, 51]),
  ('normal control 4',
   [[{'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 34},
     {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 32}]],
   [4, 51])],
 [('regression: extra point fallthrough',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 23}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33}]],
   [10, 50]),
  ('partial repair probe: extra point fallthrough',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}, {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}, {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22},
     {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}]],
   [0, 0]),
  ('second regression',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 32},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}]],
   [6, 49]),
  ('normal control 1',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 34}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22}]],
   [8, 51]),
  ('normal control 2',
   [[{'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22}, {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33}]],
   [5, 50]),
  ('normal control 3',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 32},
     {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 32},
     {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22}]],
   [7, 50]),
  ('normal control 4',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 23}, {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33}]],
   [4, 40])],
 [('regression: extra point fallthrough',
   [[{'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 30}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 23},
     {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 32}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}]],
   [4, 40]),
  ('partial repair probe: extra point fallthrough',
   [[{'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 32}, {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}]],
   [-2, 0]),
  ('second regression',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}]],
   [2, 0]),
  ('normal control 1',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 23}, {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33}]],
   [4, 40]),
  ('normal control 2',
   [[{'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 34},
     {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 23}]],
   [0, 0]),
  ('normal control 3',
   [[{'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 23},
     {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33}]],
   [0, 0]),
  ('normal control 4',
   [[{'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 21},
     {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 32}]],
   [0, 38])]]
for label, args, expected in fixtures[N-1]:
    check(label, solve(*args), expected)
print(json.dumps({"observations": observations, "passed": all(x["passed"] for x in observations)}, ensure_ascii=False))
raise SystemExit(0 if all(x["passed"] for x in observations) else 1)
Boundary fixtureActualExpectedOutcome
regression: extra point fallthrough[2, 50][4, 50]Failed
partial repair probe: extra point fallthrough[6, 50][8, 50]Failed
second regression[19, 53][7, 53]Failed
normal control 1[8, 60][8, 60]Passed
normal control 2[5, 50][5, 50]Passed
normal control 3[6, 39][6, 39]Passed
normal control 4[12, 51][12, 51]Passed

SHA-256 / 6289375ae1eeac7a39b9db175bb6d3f329a2d1570cc7688e6afceafdba241025

2 / The unsuccessful fix

Exit 1
"""Failure Map reference implementation. Python standard library only."""
import json

N = 1
observations = []
def solve(kicks):
    pts = 0
    longest = 0
    for k in kicks:
        if k['type'] == 'pat':
            if k['result'] == 'made':
                pts += 1
            elif k['result'] == 'missed':
                pts -= 1
            if k['result'] == 'made':
                continue
        dist = k['yardline'] + 17
        if k['result'] == 'made':
            pts += 3 if dist <= 39 else 4 if dist <= 49 else 5
            longest = max(longest, dist)
        elif k['result'] == 'missed':
            pts += -2 if dist <= 39 else -1 if dist <= 49 else 0
    return [pts, longest]
def check(label, actual, expected):
    observations.append({"check": label, "actual": actual, "expected": expected, "passed": actual == expected})
fixtures = [[('regression: extra point fallthrough',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33}, {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}]],
   [4, 50]),
  ('partial repair probe: extra point fallthrough',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33}, {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 32}]],
   [8, 50]),
  ('second regression',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 36}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}, {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22}]],
   [7, 53]),
  ('normal control 1',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 28}, {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 32},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 43}]],
   [8, 60]),
  ('normal control 2', [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33}]], [5, 50]),
  ('normal control 3',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22}, {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 4}, {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22}]],
   [6, 39]),
  ('normal control 4',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 32}, {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33},
     {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 2}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22},
     {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 34}]],
   [12, 51])],
 [('regression: extra point fallthrough',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 23}, {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 2},
     {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}, {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 32},
     {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}]],
   [2, 40]),
  ('partial repair probe: extra point fallthrough',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 23}, {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22}]],
   [6, 40]),
  ('second regression',
   [[{'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 25}, {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 32},
     {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22}]],
   [0, 0]),
  ('normal control 1',
   [[{'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22},
     {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 23}]],
   [4, 40]),
  ('normal control 2',
   [[{'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 6}, {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22}]],
   [-1, 39]),
  ('normal control 3', [[{'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 34}]], [0, 0]),
  ('normal control 4', [[{'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22}]], [-2, 0])],
 [('regression: extra point fallthrough',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}]],
   [2, 0]),
  ('partial repair probe: extra point fallthrough',
   [[{'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 32}, {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22}]],
   [2, 39]),
  ('second regression',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 23}, {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 34},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 23}, {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 34}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}]],
   [14, 51]),
  ('normal control 1',
   [[{'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22},
     {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 23}]],
   [-2, 0]),
  ('normal control 2', [[{'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33}]], [0, 0]),
  ('normal control 3',
   [[{'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 11},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33}, {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 34}]],
   [13, 51]),
  ('normal control 4',
   [[{'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 34},
     {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 32}]],
   [4, 51])],
 [('regression: extra point fallthrough',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 23}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33}]],
   [10, 50]),
  ('partial repair probe: extra point fallthrough',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}, {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}, {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22},
     {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}]],
   [0, 0]),
  ('second regression',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 32},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}]],
   [6, 49]),
  ('normal control 1',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 34}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22}]],
   [8, 51]),
  ('normal control 2',
   [[{'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22}, {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33}]],
   [5, 50]),
  ('normal control 3',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 32},
     {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 32},
     {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22}]],
   [7, 50]),
  ('normal control 4',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 23}, {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33}]],
   [4, 40])],
 [('regression: extra point fallthrough',
   [[{'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 30}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 23},
     {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 32}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}]],
   [4, 40]),
  ('partial repair probe: extra point fallthrough',
   [[{'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 32}, {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}]],
   [-2, 0]),
  ('second regression',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}]],
   [2, 0]),
  ('normal control 1',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 23}, {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33}]],
   [4, 40]),
  ('normal control 2',
   [[{'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 34},
     {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 23}]],
   [0, 0]),
  ('normal control 3',
   [[{'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 23},
     {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33}]],
   [0, 0]),
  ('normal control 4',
   [[{'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 21},
     {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 32}]],
   [0, 38])]]
for label, args, expected in fixtures[N-1]:
    check(label, solve(*args), expected)
print(json.dumps({"observations": observations, "passed": all(x["passed"] for x in observations)}, ensure_ascii=False))
raise SystemExit(0 if all(x["passed"] for x in observations) else 1)
Boundary fixtureActualExpectedOutcome
regression: extra point fallthrough[2, 50][4, 50]Failed
partial repair probe: extra point fallthrough[6, 50][8, 50]Failed
second regression[7, 53][7, 53]Passed
normal control 1[8, 60][8, 60]Passed
normal control 2[5, 50][5, 50]Passed
normal control 3[6, 39][6, 39]Passed
normal control 4[12, 51][12, 51]Passed

SHA-256 / 54c12f4e613277da8c432377606dbeb3b9fa5e80e5b37b678aa267d5573e8209

3 / The verified repair

Exit 0
"""Failure Map reference implementation. Python standard library only."""
import json

N = 1
observations = []
def solve(kicks):
    pts = 0
    longest = 0
    for k in kicks:
        if k['type'] == 'pat':
            if k['result'] == 'made':
                pts += 1
            elif k['result'] == 'missed':
                pts -= 1
            continue
        dist = k['yardline'] + 17
        if k['result'] == 'made':
            pts += 3 if dist <= 39 else 4 if dist <= 49 else 5
            longest = max(longest, dist)
        elif k['result'] == 'missed':
            pts += -2 if dist <= 39 else -1 if dist <= 49 else 0
    return [pts, longest]
def check(label, actual, expected):
    observations.append({"check": label, "actual": actual, "expected": expected, "passed": actual == expected})
fixtures = [[('regression: extra point fallthrough',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33}, {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}]],
   [4, 50]),
  ('partial repair probe: extra point fallthrough',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33}, {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 32}]],
   [8, 50]),
  ('second regression',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 36}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}, {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22}]],
   [7, 53]),
  ('normal control 1',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 28}, {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 32},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 43}]],
   [8, 60]),
  ('normal control 2', [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33}]], [5, 50]),
  ('normal control 3',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22}, {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 4}, {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22}]],
   [6, 39]),
  ('normal control 4',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 32}, {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33},
     {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 2}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22},
     {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 34}]],
   [12, 51])],
 [('regression: extra point fallthrough',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 23}, {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 2},
     {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}, {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 32},
     {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}]],
   [2, 40]),
  ('partial repair probe: extra point fallthrough',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 23}, {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22}]],
   [6, 40]),
  ('second regression',
   [[{'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 25}, {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 32},
     {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22}]],
   [0, 0]),
  ('normal control 1',
   [[{'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22},
     {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 23}]],
   [4, 40]),
  ('normal control 2',
   [[{'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 6}, {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22}]],
   [-1, 39]),
  ('normal control 3', [[{'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 34}]], [0, 0]),
  ('normal control 4', [[{'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22}]], [-2, 0])],
 [('regression: extra point fallthrough',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}]],
   [2, 0]),
  ('partial repair probe: extra point fallthrough',
   [[{'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 32}, {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22}]],
   [2, 39]),
  ('second regression',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 23}, {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 34},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 23}, {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 34}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}]],
   [14, 51]),
  ('normal control 1',
   [[{'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22},
     {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 23}]],
   [-2, 0]),
  ('normal control 2', [[{'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33}]], [0, 0]),
  ('normal control 3',
   [[{'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 11},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33}, {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 34}]],
   [13, 51]),
  ('normal control 4',
   [[{'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 34},
     {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 32}]],
   [4, 51])],
 [('regression: extra point fallthrough',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 23}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33}]],
   [10, 50]),
  ('partial repair probe: extra point fallthrough',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}, {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}, {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22},
     {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}]],
   [0, 0]),
  ('second regression',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 32},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}]],
   [6, 49]),
  ('normal control 1',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 34}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22}]],
   [8, 51]),
  ('normal control 2',
   [[{'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22}, {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33}]],
   [5, 50]),
  ('normal control 3',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 32},
     {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 32},
     {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22}]],
   [7, 50]),
  ('normal control 4',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 23}, {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33}]],
   [4, 40])],
 [('regression: extra point fallthrough',
   [[{'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 30}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 23},
     {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 32}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}]],
   [4, 40]),
  ('partial repair probe: extra point fallthrough',
   [[{'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 32}, {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15},
     {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}]],
   [-2, 0]),
  ('second regression',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'pat', 'yardline': 15}]],
   [2, 0]),
  ('normal control 1',
   [[{'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 23}, {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33}]],
   [4, 40]),
  ('normal control 2',
   [[{'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 34},
     {'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 23}]],
   [0, 0]),
  ('normal control 3',
   [[{'result': 'blocked', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 23},
     {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 33}]],
   [0, 0]),
  ('normal control 4',
   [[{'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 22}, {'result': 'made', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 21},
     {'result': 'missed', 'type': 'fg', 'yardline': 32}]],
   [0, 38])]]
for label, args, expected in fixtures[N-1]:
    check(label, solve(*args), expected)
print(json.dumps({"observations": observations, "passed": all(x["passed"] for x in observations)}, ensure_ascii=False))
raise SystemExit(0 if all(x["passed"] for x in observations) else 1)
Boundary fixtureActualExpectedOutcome
regression: extra point fallthrough[4, 50][4, 50]Passed
partial repair probe: extra point fallthrough[8, 50][8, 50]Passed
second regression[7, 53][7, 53]Passed
normal control 1[8, 60][8, 60]Passed
normal control 2[5, 50][5, 50]Passed
normal control 3[6, 39][6, 39]Passed
normal control 4[12, 51][12, 51]Passed

SHA-256 / 71c14626ef7f2bc80dfef39bb74c577d7adc7baf331e25c4468f8b9f0b88d091

Verification & scope

A deterministic toy scoring contract stipulated for this example; it is not the rulebook of any real fantasy platform. This reproducer isolates one failure mechanism. Results cover the supplied fixtures. Variants within a family share a test contract and should remain grouped when constructing evaluation splits. Related mechanisms with a shared evaluation_group must also remain together; these controlled models are not independent production incidents.

Observations recorded using Python 3.12.14 at 2026-09-29T14:50:35.419639+00:00.

Case digest / d16ea40b8a690513589a95d341f0269d71f944fd6e3f1c4f868c15f8a2c16a0b