FA-84881 / Fantasy sports scoring / Open access
Points allowed tier upper bounds treated as exclusive · case 01
A defense allowing exactly 6 points lands in the 7-13 tier.
ROOT CAUSE
The tier scan compares pa < limit although each tier limit is an inclusive maximum.
VERIFIED REPAIR
Compare pa <= limit so each listed maximum belongs to its own tier.
Unsuccessful approach: Moving only the shutout limit to 1 repairs zero points allowed but every other tier edge stays shifted.
Case contract
Score a team defense/special teams unit in hundredths. Points allowed exclude points the opponent scored on returns against our offense. Tiers: 0 -> 10, 1-6 -> 7, 7-13 -> 4, 14-20 -> 1, 21-27 -> 0, 28-34 -> -1, 35+ -> -4. Yards allowed: <=99 -> 5, 100-199 -> 3, 200-299 -> 2, 300-349 -> 0, 350-399 -> -1, 400-449 -> -3, 450+ -> -5. Sacks are recorded in half-sack units and score 1 per full sack (0.5 per half). Interceptions and opponent fumbles recovered 2 each (own fumble recoveries score nothing), safety 2, defensive or special-teams TD 6, blocked kick 2.
Why this case matters
Defense scoring hinges on tier boundaries and on which points count against the defense, the most disputed part of weekly scoring.
1 / The failure
Exit 1"""Failure Map reference implementation. Python standard library only."""
import json
N = 1
observations = []
def solve(game):
pa = game['pa_total'] - game['pa_offense_returns']
tiers = [(0, 1000), (6, 700), (13, 400), (20, 100), (27, 0), (34, -100)]
pts = -400
for limit, value in tiers:
if pa < limit:
pts = value
break
ya = game['yards_allowed']
ytiers = [(99, 500), (199, 300), (299, 200), (349, 0), (399, -100), (449, -300)]
ypts = -500
for limit, value in ytiers:
if ya <= limit:
ypts = value
break
pts += ypts
pts += game['sack_halves'] * 50
pts += game['ints'] * 200 + game['fum_rec'] * 200
pts += game['safeties'] * 200
pts += (game['def_td'] + game['st_td']) * 600
pts += game['blocked_kicks'] * 200
return pts
def check(label, actual, expected):
observations.append({"check": label, "actual": actual, "expected": expected, "passed": actual == expected})
fixtures = [[('regression: points allowed tier comparator',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 1,
'ints': 2,
'own_fum_rec': 0,
'pa_offense_returns': 2,
'pa_total': 15,
'sack_halves': 6,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 200}],
2500),
('partial repair probe: points allowed tier comparator',
[{'blocked_kicks': 0,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 2,
'ints': 3,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 0,
'pa_total': 20,
'sack_halves': 4,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 100}],
2800),
('second regression',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 1,
'ints': 1,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 6,
'pa_total': 6,
'sack_halves': 9,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 300}],
2650),
('normal control 1',
[{'blocked_kicks': 0,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 1,
'ints': 2,
'own_fum_rec': 0,
'pa_offense_returns': 2,
'pa_total': 9,
'sack_halves': 9,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 272}],
2250),
('normal control 2',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 1,
'ints': 2,
'own_fum_rec': 0,
'pa_offense_returns': 0,
'pa_total': 43,
'sack_halves': 6,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 299}],
2100),
('normal control 3',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 1,
'ints': 3,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 7,
'pa_total': 21,
'sack_halves': 7,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 99}],
2750),
('normal control 4',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 0,
'ints': 2,
'own_fum_rec': 1,
'pa_offense_returns': 7,
'pa_total': 42,
'sack_halves': 9,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 99}],
1150)],
[('regression: points allowed tier comparator',
[{'blocked_kicks': 0,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 0,
'ints': 3,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 7,
'pa_total': 34,
'sack_halves': 4,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 200}],
1200),
('partial repair probe: points allowed tier comparator',
[{'blocked_kicks': 0,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 2,
'ints': 2,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 0,
'pa_total': 13,
'sack_halves': 9,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 449}],
2550),
('second regression',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 0,
'ints': 3,
'own_fum_rec': 0,
'pa_offense_returns': 7,
'pa_total': 7,
'sack_halves': 6,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 450}],
3000),
('normal control 1',
[{'blocked_kicks': 0,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 1,
'ints': 0,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 2,
'pa_total': 23,
'sack_halves': 1,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 449}],
750),
('normal control 2',
[{'blocked_kicks': 0,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 1,
'ints': 3,
'own_fum_rec': 1,
'pa_offense_returns': 6,
'pa_total': 20,
'sack_halves': 1,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 400}],
850),
('normal control 3',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 0,
'ints': 3,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 2,
'pa_total': 9,
'sack_halves': 6,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 100}],
2400),
('normal control 4',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 0,
'ints': 3,
'own_fum_rec': 0,
'pa_offense_returns': 2,
'pa_total': 30,
'sack_halves': 5,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 99}],
2250)],
[('regression: points allowed tier comparator',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 2,
'ints': 3,
'own_fum_rec': 1,
'pa_offense_returns': 0,
'pa_total': 0,
'sack_halves': 7,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 449}],
3050),
('partial repair probe: points allowed tier comparator',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 0,
'ints': 2,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 6,
'pa_total': 12,
'sack_halves': 3,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 400}],
1750),
('second regression',
[{'blocked_kicks': 0,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 1,
'ints': 1,
'own_fum_rec': 0,
'pa_offense_returns': 0,
'pa_total': 34,
'sack_halves': 3,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 449}],
950),
('normal control 1',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 1,
'ints': 1,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 6,
'pa_total': 41,
'sack_halves': 8,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 300}],
1200),
('normal control 2',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 1,
'ints': 3,
'own_fum_rec': 1,
'pa_offense_returns': 0,
'pa_total': 35,
'sack_halves': 5,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 200}],
2250),
('normal control 3',
[{'blocked_kicks': 0,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 1,
'ints': 0,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 0,
'pa_total': 4,
'sack_halves': 1,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 449}],
1250),
('normal control 4',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 2,
'ints': 0,
'own_fum_rec': 0,
'pa_offense_returns': 0,
'pa_total': 14,
'sack_halves': 3,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 183}],
1350)],
[('regression: points allowed tier comparator',
[{'blocked_kicks': 0,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 0,
'ints': 0,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 2,
'pa_total': 2,
'sack_halves': 4,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 495}],
1300),
('partial repair probe: points allowed tier comparator',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 2,
'ints': 3,
'own_fum_rec': 0,
'pa_offense_returns': 6,
'pa_total': 33,
'sack_halves': 9,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 199}],
2750),
('second regression',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 0,
'ints': 2,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 0,
'pa_total': 13,
'sack_halves': 5,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 300}],
1850),
('normal control 1',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 1,
'ints': 0,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 7,
'pa_total': 14,
'sack_halves': 1,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 450}],
1750),
('normal control 2',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 0,
'ints': 2,
'own_fum_rec': 0,
'pa_offense_returns': 2,
'pa_total': 40,
'sack_halves': 7,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 100}],
850),
('normal control 3',
[{'blocked_kicks': 0,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 0,
'ints': 2,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 7,
'pa_total': 42,
'sack_halves': 5,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 400}],
-50),
('normal control 4',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 0,
'ints': 0,
'own_fum_rec': 0,
'pa_offense_returns': 0,
'pa_total': 35,
'sack_halves': 3,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 299}],
1550)],
[('regression: points allowed tier comparator',
[{'blocked_kicks': 0,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 2,
'ints': 3,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 2,
'pa_total': 2,
'sack_halves': 4,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 349}],
3600),
('partial repair probe: points allowed tier comparator',
[{'blocked_kicks': 0,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 0,
'ints': 3,
'own_fum_rec': 1,
'pa_offense_returns': 7,
'pa_total': 34,
'sack_halves': 2,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 200}],
1100),
('second regression',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 2,
'ints': 0,
'own_fum_rec': 1,
'pa_offense_returns': 6,
'pa_total': 6,
'sack_halves': 1,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 399}],
2150),
('normal control 1',
[{'blocked_kicks': 0,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 1,
'ints': 0,
'own_fum_rec': 0,
'pa_offense_returns': 0,
'pa_total': 14,
'sack_halves': 4,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 170}],
1400),
('normal control 2',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 2,
'ints': 1,
'own_fum_rec': 0,
'pa_offense_returns': 6,
'pa_total': 20,
'sack_halves': 8,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 349}],
1900),
('normal control 3',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 2,
'ints': 2,
'own_fum_rec': 0,
'pa_offense_returns': 7,
'pa_total': 30,
'sack_halves': 3,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 449}],
1450),
('normal control 4',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 0,
'ints': 1,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 7,
'pa_total': 21,
'sack_halves': 0,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 99}],
2200)]]
for label, args, expected in fixtures[N-1]:
check(label, solve(*args), expected)
print(json.dumps({"observations": observations, "passed": all(x["passed"] for x in observations)}, ensure_ascii=False))
raise SystemExit(0 if all(x["passed"] for x in observations) else 1)
| Boundary fixture | Actual | Expected | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| regression: points allowed tier comparator | 2200 | 2500 | Failed |
| partial repair probe: points allowed tier comparator | 2700 | 2800 | Failed |
| second regression | 2350 | 2650 | Failed |
| normal control 1 | 2250 | 2250 | Passed |
| normal control 2 | 2100 | 2100 | Passed |
| normal control 3 | 2750 | 2750 | Passed |
| normal control 4 | 1150 | 1150 | Passed |
SHA-256 / c8f97dc3eb8cabac420fbe5ff20a5cb402248f8ee6ccf9b59bc6f9b111c01f30
2 / The unsuccessful fix
Exit 1"""Failure Map reference implementation. Python standard library only."""
import json
N = 1
observations = []
def solve(game):
pa = game['pa_total'] - game['pa_offense_returns']
tiers = [(1, 1000), (6, 700), (13, 400), (20, 100), (27, 0), (34, -100)]
pts = -400
for limit, value in tiers:
if pa < limit:
pts = value
break
ya = game['yards_allowed']
ytiers = [(99, 500), (199, 300), (299, 200), (349, 0), (399, -100), (449, -300)]
ypts = -500
for limit, value in ytiers:
if ya <= limit:
ypts = value
break
pts += ypts
pts += game['sack_halves'] * 50
pts += game['ints'] * 200 + game['fum_rec'] * 200
pts += game['safeties'] * 200
pts += (game['def_td'] + game['st_td']) * 600
pts += game['blocked_kicks'] * 200
return pts
def check(label, actual, expected):
observations.append({"check": label, "actual": actual, "expected": expected, "passed": actual == expected})
fixtures = [[('regression: points allowed tier comparator',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 1,
'ints': 2,
'own_fum_rec': 0,
'pa_offense_returns': 2,
'pa_total': 15,
'sack_halves': 6,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 200}],
2500),
('partial repair probe: points allowed tier comparator',
[{'blocked_kicks': 0,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 2,
'ints': 3,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 0,
'pa_total': 20,
'sack_halves': 4,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 100}],
2800),
('second regression',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 1,
'ints': 1,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 6,
'pa_total': 6,
'sack_halves': 9,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 300}],
2650),
('normal control 1',
[{'blocked_kicks': 0,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 1,
'ints': 2,
'own_fum_rec': 0,
'pa_offense_returns': 2,
'pa_total': 9,
'sack_halves': 9,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 272}],
2250),
('normal control 2',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 1,
'ints': 2,
'own_fum_rec': 0,
'pa_offense_returns': 0,
'pa_total': 43,
'sack_halves': 6,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 299}],
2100),
('normal control 3',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 1,
'ints': 3,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 7,
'pa_total': 21,
'sack_halves': 7,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 99}],
2750),
('normal control 4',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 0,
'ints': 2,
'own_fum_rec': 1,
'pa_offense_returns': 7,
'pa_total': 42,
'sack_halves': 9,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 99}],
1150)],
[('regression: points allowed tier comparator',
[{'blocked_kicks': 0,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 0,
'ints': 3,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 7,
'pa_total': 34,
'sack_halves': 4,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 200}],
1200),
('partial repair probe: points allowed tier comparator',
[{'blocked_kicks': 0,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 2,
'ints': 2,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 0,
'pa_total': 13,
'sack_halves': 9,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 449}],
2550),
('second regression',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 0,
'ints': 3,
'own_fum_rec': 0,
'pa_offense_returns': 7,
'pa_total': 7,
'sack_halves': 6,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 450}],
3000),
('normal control 1',
[{'blocked_kicks': 0,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 1,
'ints': 0,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 2,
'pa_total': 23,
'sack_halves': 1,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 449}],
750),
('normal control 2',
[{'blocked_kicks': 0,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 1,
'ints': 3,
'own_fum_rec': 1,
'pa_offense_returns': 6,
'pa_total': 20,
'sack_halves': 1,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 400}],
850),
('normal control 3',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 0,
'ints': 3,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 2,
'pa_total': 9,
'sack_halves': 6,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 100}],
2400),
('normal control 4',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 0,
'ints': 3,
'own_fum_rec': 0,
'pa_offense_returns': 2,
'pa_total': 30,
'sack_halves': 5,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 99}],
2250)],
[('regression: points allowed tier comparator',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 2,
'ints': 3,
'own_fum_rec': 1,
'pa_offense_returns': 0,
'pa_total': 0,
'sack_halves': 7,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 449}],
3050),
('partial repair probe: points allowed tier comparator',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 0,
'ints': 2,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 6,
'pa_total': 12,
'sack_halves': 3,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 400}],
1750),
('second regression',
[{'blocked_kicks': 0,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 1,
'ints': 1,
'own_fum_rec': 0,
'pa_offense_returns': 0,
'pa_total': 34,
'sack_halves': 3,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 449}],
950),
('normal control 1',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 1,
'ints': 1,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 6,
'pa_total': 41,
'sack_halves': 8,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 300}],
1200),
('normal control 2',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 1,
'ints': 3,
'own_fum_rec': 1,
'pa_offense_returns': 0,
'pa_total': 35,
'sack_halves': 5,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 200}],
2250),
('normal control 3',
[{'blocked_kicks': 0,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 1,
'ints': 0,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 0,
'pa_total': 4,
'sack_halves': 1,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 449}],
1250),
('normal control 4',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 2,
'ints': 0,
'own_fum_rec': 0,
'pa_offense_returns': 0,
'pa_total': 14,
'sack_halves': 3,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 183}],
1350)],
[('regression: points allowed tier comparator',
[{'blocked_kicks': 0,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 0,
'ints': 0,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 2,
'pa_total': 2,
'sack_halves': 4,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 495}],
1300),
('partial repair probe: points allowed tier comparator',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 2,
'ints': 3,
'own_fum_rec': 0,
'pa_offense_returns': 6,
'pa_total': 33,
'sack_halves': 9,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 199}],
2750),
('second regression',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 0,
'ints': 2,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 0,
'pa_total': 13,
'sack_halves': 5,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 300}],
1850),
('normal control 1',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 1,
'ints': 0,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 7,
'pa_total': 14,
'sack_halves': 1,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 450}],
1750),
('normal control 2',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 0,
'ints': 2,
'own_fum_rec': 0,
'pa_offense_returns': 2,
'pa_total': 40,
'sack_halves': 7,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 100}],
850),
('normal control 3',
[{'blocked_kicks': 0,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 0,
'ints': 2,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 7,
'pa_total': 42,
'sack_halves': 5,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 400}],
-50),
('normal control 4',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 0,
'ints': 0,
'own_fum_rec': 0,
'pa_offense_returns': 0,
'pa_total': 35,
'sack_halves': 3,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 299}],
1550)],
[('regression: points allowed tier comparator',
[{'blocked_kicks': 0,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 2,
'ints': 3,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 2,
'pa_total': 2,
'sack_halves': 4,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 349}],
3600),
('partial repair probe: points allowed tier comparator',
[{'blocked_kicks': 0,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 0,
'ints': 3,
'own_fum_rec': 1,
'pa_offense_returns': 7,
'pa_total': 34,
'sack_halves': 2,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 200}],
1100),
('second regression',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 2,
'ints': 0,
'own_fum_rec': 1,
'pa_offense_returns': 6,
'pa_total': 6,
'sack_halves': 1,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 399}],
2150),
('normal control 1',
[{'blocked_kicks': 0,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 1,
'ints': 0,
'own_fum_rec': 0,
'pa_offense_returns': 0,
'pa_total': 14,
'sack_halves': 4,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 170}],
1400),
('normal control 2',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 2,
'ints': 1,
'own_fum_rec': 0,
'pa_offense_returns': 6,
'pa_total': 20,
'sack_halves': 8,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 349}],
1900),
('normal control 3',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 2,
'ints': 2,
'own_fum_rec': 0,
'pa_offense_returns': 7,
'pa_total': 30,
'sack_halves': 3,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 449}],
1450),
('normal control 4',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 0,
'ints': 1,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 7,
'pa_total': 21,
'sack_halves': 0,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 99}],
2200)]]
for label, args, expected in fixtures[N-1]:
check(label, solve(*args), expected)
print(json.dumps({"observations": observations, "passed": all(x["passed"] for x in observations)}, ensure_ascii=False))
raise SystemExit(0 if all(x["passed"] for x in observations) else 1)
| Boundary fixture | Actual | Expected | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| regression: points allowed tier comparator | 2200 | 2500 | Failed |
| partial repair probe: points allowed tier comparator | 2700 | 2800 | Failed |
| second regression | 2650 | 2650 | Passed |
| normal control 1 | 2250 | 2250 | Passed |
| normal control 2 | 2100 | 2100 | Passed |
| normal control 3 | 2750 | 2750 | Passed |
| normal control 4 | 1150 | 1150 | Passed |
SHA-256 / 706987831a4f3a6e77e680a9c46d3e8120aa2e823eb42e9ab99e89f0d70ee9ab
3 / The verified repair
Exit 0"""Failure Map reference implementation. Python standard library only."""
import json
N = 1
observations = []
def solve(game):
pa = game['pa_total'] - game['pa_offense_returns']
tiers = [(0, 1000), (6, 700), (13, 400), (20, 100), (27, 0), (34, -100)]
pts = -400
for limit, value in tiers:
if pa <= limit:
pts = value
break
ya = game['yards_allowed']
ytiers = [(99, 500), (199, 300), (299, 200), (349, 0), (399, -100), (449, -300)]
ypts = -500
for limit, value in ytiers:
if ya <= limit:
ypts = value
break
pts += ypts
pts += game['sack_halves'] * 50
pts += game['ints'] * 200 + game['fum_rec'] * 200
pts += game['safeties'] * 200
pts += (game['def_td'] + game['st_td']) * 600
pts += game['blocked_kicks'] * 200
return pts
def check(label, actual, expected):
observations.append({"check": label, "actual": actual, "expected": expected, "passed": actual == expected})
fixtures = [[('regression: points allowed tier comparator',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 1,
'ints': 2,
'own_fum_rec': 0,
'pa_offense_returns': 2,
'pa_total': 15,
'sack_halves': 6,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 200}],
2500),
('partial repair probe: points allowed tier comparator',
[{'blocked_kicks': 0,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 2,
'ints': 3,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 0,
'pa_total': 20,
'sack_halves': 4,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 100}],
2800),
('second regression',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 1,
'ints': 1,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 6,
'pa_total': 6,
'sack_halves': 9,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 300}],
2650),
('normal control 1',
[{'blocked_kicks': 0,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 1,
'ints': 2,
'own_fum_rec': 0,
'pa_offense_returns': 2,
'pa_total': 9,
'sack_halves': 9,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 272}],
2250),
('normal control 2',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 1,
'ints': 2,
'own_fum_rec': 0,
'pa_offense_returns': 0,
'pa_total': 43,
'sack_halves': 6,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 299}],
2100),
('normal control 3',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 1,
'ints': 3,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 7,
'pa_total': 21,
'sack_halves': 7,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 99}],
2750),
('normal control 4',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 0,
'ints': 2,
'own_fum_rec': 1,
'pa_offense_returns': 7,
'pa_total': 42,
'sack_halves': 9,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 99}],
1150)],
[('regression: points allowed tier comparator',
[{'blocked_kicks': 0,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 0,
'ints': 3,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 7,
'pa_total': 34,
'sack_halves': 4,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 200}],
1200),
('partial repair probe: points allowed tier comparator',
[{'blocked_kicks': 0,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 2,
'ints': 2,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 0,
'pa_total': 13,
'sack_halves': 9,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 449}],
2550),
('second regression',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 0,
'ints': 3,
'own_fum_rec': 0,
'pa_offense_returns': 7,
'pa_total': 7,
'sack_halves': 6,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 450}],
3000),
('normal control 1',
[{'blocked_kicks': 0,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 1,
'ints': 0,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 2,
'pa_total': 23,
'sack_halves': 1,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 449}],
750),
('normal control 2',
[{'blocked_kicks': 0,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 1,
'ints': 3,
'own_fum_rec': 1,
'pa_offense_returns': 6,
'pa_total': 20,
'sack_halves': 1,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 400}],
850),
('normal control 3',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 0,
'ints': 3,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 2,
'pa_total': 9,
'sack_halves': 6,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 100}],
2400),
('normal control 4',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 0,
'ints': 3,
'own_fum_rec': 0,
'pa_offense_returns': 2,
'pa_total': 30,
'sack_halves': 5,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 99}],
2250)],
[('regression: points allowed tier comparator',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 2,
'ints': 3,
'own_fum_rec': 1,
'pa_offense_returns': 0,
'pa_total': 0,
'sack_halves': 7,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 449}],
3050),
('partial repair probe: points allowed tier comparator',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 0,
'ints': 2,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 6,
'pa_total': 12,
'sack_halves': 3,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 400}],
1750),
('second regression',
[{'blocked_kicks': 0,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 1,
'ints': 1,
'own_fum_rec': 0,
'pa_offense_returns': 0,
'pa_total': 34,
'sack_halves': 3,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 449}],
950),
('normal control 1',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 1,
'ints': 1,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 6,
'pa_total': 41,
'sack_halves': 8,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 300}],
1200),
('normal control 2',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 1,
'ints': 3,
'own_fum_rec': 1,
'pa_offense_returns': 0,
'pa_total': 35,
'sack_halves': 5,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 200}],
2250),
('normal control 3',
[{'blocked_kicks': 0,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 1,
'ints': 0,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 0,
'pa_total': 4,
'sack_halves': 1,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 449}],
1250),
('normal control 4',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 2,
'ints': 0,
'own_fum_rec': 0,
'pa_offense_returns': 0,
'pa_total': 14,
'sack_halves': 3,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 183}],
1350)],
[('regression: points allowed tier comparator',
[{'blocked_kicks': 0,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 0,
'ints': 0,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 2,
'pa_total': 2,
'sack_halves': 4,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 495}],
1300),
('partial repair probe: points allowed tier comparator',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 2,
'ints': 3,
'own_fum_rec': 0,
'pa_offense_returns': 6,
'pa_total': 33,
'sack_halves': 9,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 199}],
2750),
('second regression',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 0,
'ints': 2,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 0,
'pa_total': 13,
'sack_halves': 5,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 300}],
1850),
('normal control 1',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 1,
'ints': 0,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 7,
'pa_total': 14,
'sack_halves': 1,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 450}],
1750),
('normal control 2',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 0,
'ints': 2,
'own_fum_rec': 0,
'pa_offense_returns': 2,
'pa_total': 40,
'sack_halves': 7,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 100}],
850),
('normal control 3',
[{'blocked_kicks': 0,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 0,
'ints': 2,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 7,
'pa_total': 42,
'sack_halves': 5,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 400}],
-50),
('normal control 4',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 0,
'ints': 0,
'own_fum_rec': 0,
'pa_offense_returns': 0,
'pa_total': 35,
'sack_halves': 3,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 299}],
1550)],
[('regression: points allowed tier comparator',
[{'blocked_kicks': 0,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 2,
'ints': 3,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 2,
'pa_total': 2,
'sack_halves': 4,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 349}],
3600),
('partial repair probe: points allowed tier comparator',
[{'blocked_kicks': 0,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 0,
'ints': 3,
'own_fum_rec': 1,
'pa_offense_returns': 7,
'pa_total': 34,
'sack_halves': 2,
'safeties': 1,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 200}],
1100),
('second regression',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 2,
'ints': 0,
'own_fum_rec': 1,
'pa_offense_returns': 6,
'pa_total': 6,
'sack_halves': 1,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 399}],
2150),
('normal control 1',
[{'blocked_kicks': 0,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 1,
'ints': 0,
'own_fum_rec': 0,
'pa_offense_returns': 0,
'pa_total': 14,
'sack_halves': 4,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 0,
'yards_allowed': 170}],
1400),
('normal control 2',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 2,
'ints': 1,
'own_fum_rec': 0,
'pa_offense_returns': 6,
'pa_total': 20,
'sack_halves': 8,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 349}],
1900),
('normal control 3',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 0,
'fum_rec': 2,
'ints': 2,
'own_fum_rec': 0,
'pa_offense_returns': 7,
'pa_total': 30,
'sack_halves': 3,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 449}],
1450),
('normal control 4',
[{'blocked_kicks': 1,
'def_td': 1,
'fum_rec': 0,
'ints': 1,
'own_fum_rec': 2,
'pa_offense_returns': 7,
'pa_total': 21,
'sack_halves': 0,
'safeties': 0,
'st_td': 1,
'yards_allowed': 99}],
2200)]]
for label, args, expected in fixtures[N-1]:
check(label, solve(*args), expected)
print(json.dumps({"observations": observations, "passed": all(x["passed"] for x in observations)}, ensure_ascii=False))
raise SystemExit(0 if all(x["passed"] for x in observations) else 1)
| Boundary fixture | Actual | Expected | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| regression: points allowed tier comparator | 2500 | 2500 | Passed |
| partial repair probe: points allowed tier comparator | 2800 | 2800 | Passed |
| second regression | 2650 | 2650 | Passed |
| normal control 1 | 2250 | 2250 | Passed |
| normal control 2 | 2100 | 2100 | Passed |
| normal control 3 | 2750 | 2750 | Passed |
| normal control 4 | 1150 | 1150 | Passed |
SHA-256 / 1abc1b60f02dad63a08c19dc0561c6d92241111c50f7cb04f9b6842cc410ae2d
Verification & scope
A deterministic toy scoring contract stipulated for this example; it is not the rulebook of any real fantasy platform. This reproducer isolates one failure mechanism. Results cover the supplied fixtures. Variants within a family share a test contract and should remain grouped when constructing evaluation splits. Related mechanisms with a shared evaluation_group must also remain together; these controlled models are not independent production incidents.
Observations recorded using Python 3.12.14 at 2026-09-29T14:50:35.219530+00:00.
Case digest / 8e6addc5816fd3e2a2987f7676f7d2ae2f5ddef2203f2155395b54c909e9987f