FAILURE MAP
← Case archive

FA-65906 / Aviation weight and balance / Open access

Dry operating index gets K added a second time · case 01

Totals are high by exactly K and the aircraft looks aft-loaded even when empty.

Verified by executionVariant 1 · 9 checks per implementationDownload source bundle ↓JSON ↗

ROOT CAUSE

The accumulator treats the DOI as a raw moment index and adds K again, though the DOI already includes it.

VERIFIED REPAIR

Start the total index at the DOI unchanged.

Unsuccessful approach: Subtracting the reference arm mixes a length into an index and still offsets every result.

Case contract

Input {'dow','doi','ref','c','k','lemac','mac','items':[[kg,arm m]]}. Item index = kg*(arm-ref)/c; the dry operating index already contains K. Total index = doi + item indices; CG arm = ref + (index-K)*c/total weight; %MAC = (CG-LEMAC)/MAC*100. Return [index r2, %MAC r1].

Why this case matters

Airline loadsheets carry balance as a dimensionless index offset by K; converting back to %MAC requires removing K and scaling by C over total weight.

1 / The failure

Exit 1
"""Failure Map reference implementation. Python standard library only."""
import json

N = 1
observations = []
def solve(x):
    ref, c, k = x['ref'], x['c'], x['k']
    w = x['dow']
    ti = x['doi'] + k
    for iw, arm in x['items']:
        w += iw
        ti += iw * (arm - ref) / c
    cg = ref + (ti - k) * c / w
    pmac = (cg - x['lemac']) / x['mac'] * 100
    return [round(ti, 2), round(pmac, 1)]
def check(label, actual, expected):
    observations.append({"check": label, "actual": actual, "expected": expected, "passed": actual == expected})
fixtures = [[['typical cabin and hold', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[3100.0, 14.0], [5000.0, 19.5], [1200.0, 24.0]]}, [50.3, 37.6]], ['empty operating aircraft', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': []}, [48.0, 36.3]], ['aft hold heavy', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[4000.0, 26.1]]}, [80.4, 54.0]], ['forward hold heavy', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[3500.0, 9.2]]}, [17.2, 19.5]], ['item at reference arm', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[2500.0, 18.0]]}, [48.0, 36.4]], ['different constants', {'dow': 36050.0, 'doi': 40.0, 'ref': 20.0, 'c': 500.0, 'k': 45.0, 'lemac': 18.0, 'mac': 3.2, 'items': [[1800.0, 22.0], [2200.0, 17.0]]}, [34.0, 58.2]], ['sampled case 1', {'dow': 33485.0, 'doi': 37.0, 'ref': 20.4, 'c': 500.0, 'k': 44.4, 'lemac': 18.68, 'mac': 3.58, 'items': [[4603.0, 5.73], [2919.0, 25.41], [5509.0, 29.73], [5663.0, 28.02]]}, [120.3, 68.4]], ['sampled case 2', {'dow': 45884.0, 'doi': 51.2, 'ref': 20.0, 'c': 200.0, 'k': 57.4, 'lemac': 14.39, 'mac': 4.79, 'items': [[4694.0, 15.31], [4327.0, 9.7], [185.0, 15.41], [4752.0, 22.51], [992.0, 14.27]]}, [-254.74, 95.7]], ['sampled case 3', {'dow': 36007.0, 'doi': 45.2, 'ref': 20.5, 'c': 2000.0, 'k': 46.9, 'lemac': 17.4, 'mac': 3.61, 'items': []}, [45.2, 83.3]]], [['typical cabin and hold', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[3200.0, 14.0], [5000.0, 19.5], [1200.0, 24.0]]}, [49.9, 37.5]], ['empty operating aircraft', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': []}, [48.0, 36.3]], ['aft hold heavy', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[4000.0, 26.2]]}, [80.8, 54.2]], ['forward hold heavy', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[3500.0, 9.4]]}, [17.9, 19.9]], ['item at reference arm', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[5000.0, 18.0]]}, [48.0, 36.4]], ['different constants', {'dow': 36100.0, 'doi': 40.0, 'ref': 20.0, 'c': 500.0, 'k': 45.0, 'lemac': 18.0, 'mac': 3.2, 'items': [[1800.0, 22.0], [2200.0, 17.0]]}, [34.0, 58.2]], ['sampled case 1', {'dow': 41485.0, 'doi': 53.7, 'ref': 17.2, 'c': 500.0, 'k': 53.6, 'lemac': 14.91, 'mac': 4.7, 'items': [[323.0, 8.3], [3020.0, 17.98], [2440.0, 14.22]]}, [38.12, 45.2]], ['sampled case 2', {'dow': 36221.0, 'doi': 55.1, 'ref': 19.8, 'c': 2000.0, 'k': 56.4, 'lemac': 18.06, 'mac': 3.42, 'items': [[1053.0, 22.91]]}, [56.74, 51.4]], ['sampled case 3', {'dow': 36359.0, 'doi': 27.6, 'ref': 16.4, 'c': 200.0, 'k': 30.8, 'lemac': 14.16, 'mac': 3.79, 'items': [[2072.0, 5.02]]}, [-90.3, 42.5]]], [['typical cabin and hold', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[3300.0, 14.0], [5000.0, 19.5], [1200.0, 24.0]]}, [49.5, 37.3]], ['empty operating aircraft', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': []}, [48.0, 36.3]], ['aft hold heavy', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[4000.0, 26.3]]}, [81.2, 54.5]], ['forward hold heavy', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[3500.0, 9.6]]}, [18.6, 20.2]], ['item at reference arm', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[7500.0, 18.0]]}, [48.0, 36.5]], ['different constants', {'dow': 36150.0, 'doi': 40.0, 'ref': 20.0, 'c': 500.0, 'k': 45.0, 'lemac': 18.0, 'mac': 3.2, 'items': [[1800.0, 22.0], [2200.0, 17.0]]}, [34.0, 58.2]], ['sampled case 1', {'dow': 33923.0, 'doi': 39.1, 'ref': 19.3, 'c': 200.0, 'k': 45.3, 'lemac': 16.18, 'mac': 4.5, 'items': [[3739.0, 10.15]]}, [-131.96, 48.4]], ['sampled case 2', {'dow': 40403.0, 'doi': 39.1, 'ref': 21.4, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 44.8, 'lemac': 14.64, 'mac': 4.94, 'items': [[4674.0, 28.04]]}, [70.14, 148.2]], ['sampled case 3', {'dow': 30111.0, 'doi': 38.1, 'ref': 15.0, 'c': 200.0, 'k': 36.0, 'lemac': 15.26, 'mac': 4.8, 'items': [[5589.0, 17.22]]}, [100.14, 2.1]]], [['typical cabin and hold', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[3400.0, 14.0], [5000.0, 19.5], [1200.0, 24.0]]}, [49.1, 37.1]], ['empty operating aircraft', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': []}, [48.0, 36.3]], ['aft hold heavy', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[4000.0, 26.4]]}, [81.6, 54.7]], ['forward hold heavy', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[3500.0, 9.8]]}, [19.3, 20.6]], ['item at reference arm', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[10000.0, 18.0]]}, [48.0, 36.5]], ['different constants', {'dow': 36200.0, 'doi': 40.0, 'ref': 20.0, 'c': 500.0, 'k': 45.0, 'lemac': 18.0, 'mac': 3.2, 'items': [[1800.0, 22.0], [2200.0, 17.0]]}, [34.0, 58.2]], ['sampled case 1', {'dow': 40381.0, 'doi': 38.2, 'ref': 17.2, 'c': 200.0, 'k': 35.3, 'lemac': 17.91, 'mac': 3.25, 'items': [[1141.0, 14.25], [3763.0, 12.45]]}, [-68.0, -35.9]], ['sampled case 2', {'dow': 40833.0, 'doi': 53.7, 'ref': 21.5, 'c': 2000.0, 'k': 48.5, 'lemac': 17.83, 'mac': 3.22, 'items': [[4174.0, 19.61], [2120.0, 18.46], [4779.0, 27.55], [1973.0, 12.04]]}, [51.66, 117.6]], ['sampled case 3', {'dow': 33856.0, 'doi': 31.0, 'ref': 19.9, 'c': 200.0, 'k': 36.6, 'lemac': 18.08, 'mac': 4.82, 'items': []}, [31.0, 37.1]]], [['typical cabin and hold', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[3500.0, 14.0], [5000.0, 19.5], [1200.0, 24.0]]}, [48.7, 36.9]], ['empty operating aircraft', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': []}, [48.0, 36.3]], ['aft hold heavy', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[4000.0, 26.5]]}, [82.0, 54.9]], ['forward hold heavy', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[3500.0, 10.0]]}, [20.0, 21.0]], ['item at reference arm', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[12500.0, 18.0]]}, [48.0, 36.6]], ['different constants', {'dow': 36250.0, 'doi': 40.0, 'ref': 20.0, 'c': 500.0, 'k': 45.0, 'lemac': 18.0, 'mac': 3.2, 'items': [[1800.0, 22.0], [2200.0, 17.0]]}, [34.0, 58.2]], ['sampled case 1', {'dow': 34075.0, 'doi': 33.7, 'ref': 19.6, 'c': 2000.0, 'k': 36.1, 'lemac': 15.76, 'mac': 3.12, 'items': [[4801.0, 23.6], [3956.0, 16.47], [1810.0, 18.75], [1491.0, 15.01], [3514.0, 6.44]]}, [9.8, 89.1]], ['sampled case 2', {'dow': 33834.0, 'doi': 57.4, 'ref': 20.6, 'c': 500.0, 'k': 55.3, 'lemac': 15.75, 'mac': 3.95, 'items': [[3292.0, 11.8], [4846.0, 14.0], [3222.0, 25.52], [2090.0, 7.1], [168.0, 27.97]]}, [-86.76, 84.9]], ['sampled case 3', {'dow': 46921.0, 'doi': 51.0, 'ref': 17.8, 'c': 500.0, 'k': 52.3, 'lemac': 14.61, 'mac': 3.01, 'items': [[2487.0, 11.85], [4542.0, 19.68]]}, [38.48, 101.7]]]]
for label, args, expected in fixtures[N-1]:
    check(label, solve(args), expected)
print(json.dumps({"observations": observations, "passed": all(x["passed"] for x in observations)}, ensure_ascii=False))
raise SystemExit(0 if all(x["passed"] for x in observations) else 1)
Boundary fixtureActualExpectedOutcome
typical cabin and hold[100.3, 62.0][50.3, 37.6]Failed
empty operating aircraft[98.0, 66.1][48.0, 36.3]Failed
aft hold heavy[130.4, 81.2][80.4, 54.0]Failed
forward hold heavy[67.2, 47.0][17.2, 19.5]Failed
item at reference arm[98.0, 64.5][48.0, 36.4]Failed
different constants[79.0, 75.8][34.0, 58.2]Failed
sampled case 1[164.7, 80.2][120.3, 68.4]Failed
sampled case 2[-197.34, 99.6][-254.74, 95.7]Failed
sampled case 3[92.1, 155.4][45.2, 83.3]Failed

SHA-256 / 89adf55f84335336d5a91f64f4c2fa94fda7a7516269e3f32e831883ee5cff71

2 / The unsuccessful fix

Exit 1
"""Failure Map reference implementation. Python standard library only."""
import json

N = 1
observations = []
def solve(x):
    ref, c, k = x['ref'], x['c'], x['k']
    w = x['dow']
    ti = x['doi'] - ref
    for iw, arm in x['items']:
        w += iw
        ti += iw * (arm - ref) / c
    cg = ref + (ti - k) * c / w
    pmac = (cg - x['lemac']) / x['mac'] * 100
    return [round(ti, 2), round(pmac, 1)]
def check(label, actual, expected):
    observations.append({"check": label, "actual": actual, "expected": expected, "passed": actual == expected})
fixtures = [[['typical cabin and hold', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[3100.0, 14.0], [5000.0, 19.5], [1200.0, 24.0]]}, [50.3, 37.6]], ['empty operating aircraft', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': []}, [48.0, 36.3]], ['aft hold heavy', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[4000.0, 26.1]]}, [80.4, 54.0]], ['forward hold heavy', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[3500.0, 9.2]]}, [17.2, 19.5]], ['item at reference arm', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[2500.0, 18.0]]}, [48.0, 36.4]], ['different constants', {'dow': 36050.0, 'doi': 40.0, 'ref': 20.0, 'c': 500.0, 'k': 45.0, 'lemac': 18.0, 'mac': 3.2, 'items': [[1800.0, 22.0], [2200.0, 17.0]]}, [34.0, 58.2]], ['sampled case 1', {'dow': 33485.0, 'doi': 37.0, 'ref': 20.4, 'c': 500.0, 'k': 44.4, 'lemac': 18.68, 'mac': 3.58, 'items': [[4603.0, 5.73], [2919.0, 25.41], [5509.0, 29.73], [5663.0, 28.02]]}, [120.3, 68.4]], ['sampled case 2', {'dow': 45884.0, 'doi': 51.2, 'ref': 20.0, 'c': 200.0, 'k': 57.4, 'lemac': 14.39, 'mac': 4.79, 'items': [[4694.0, 15.31], [4327.0, 9.7], [185.0, 15.41], [4752.0, 22.51], [992.0, 14.27]]}, [-254.74, 95.7]], ['sampled case 3', {'dow': 36007.0, 'doi': 45.2, 'ref': 20.5, 'c': 2000.0, 'k': 46.9, 'lemac': 17.4, 'mac': 3.61, 'items': []}, [45.2, 83.3]]], [['typical cabin and hold', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[3200.0, 14.0], [5000.0, 19.5], [1200.0, 24.0]]}, [49.9, 37.5]], ['empty operating aircraft', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': []}, [48.0, 36.3]], ['aft hold heavy', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[4000.0, 26.2]]}, [80.8, 54.2]], ['forward hold heavy', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[3500.0, 9.4]]}, [17.9, 19.9]], ['item at reference arm', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[5000.0, 18.0]]}, [48.0, 36.4]], ['different constants', {'dow': 36100.0, 'doi': 40.0, 'ref': 20.0, 'c': 500.0, 'k': 45.0, 'lemac': 18.0, 'mac': 3.2, 'items': [[1800.0, 22.0], [2200.0, 17.0]]}, [34.0, 58.2]], ['sampled case 1', {'dow': 41485.0, 'doi': 53.7, 'ref': 17.2, 'c': 500.0, 'k': 53.6, 'lemac': 14.91, 'mac': 4.7, 'items': [[323.0, 8.3], [3020.0, 17.98], [2440.0, 14.22]]}, [38.12, 45.2]], ['sampled case 2', {'dow': 36221.0, 'doi': 55.1, 'ref': 19.8, 'c': 2000.0, 'k': 56.4, 'lemac': 18.06, 'mac': 3.42, 'items': [[1053.0, 22.91]]}, [56.74, 51.4]], ['sampled case 3', {'dow': 36359.0, 'doi': 27.6, 'ref': 16.4, 'c': 200.0, 'k': 30.8, 'lemac': 14.16, 'mac': 3.79, 'items': [[2072.0, 5.02]]}, [-90.3, 42.5]]], [['typical cabin and hold', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[3300.0, 14.0], [5000.0, 19.5], [1200.0, 24.0]]}, [49.5, 37.3]], ['empty operating aircraft', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': []}, [48.0, 36.3]], ['aft hold heavy', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[4000.0, 26.3]]}, [81.2, 54.5]], ['forward hold heavy', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[3500.0, 9.6]]}, [18.6, 20.2]], ['item at reference arm', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[7500.0, 18.0]]}, [48.0, 36.5]], ['different constants', {'dow': 36150.0, 'doi': 40.0, 'ref': 20.0, 'c': 500.0, 'k': 45.0, 'lemac': 18.0, 'mac': 3.2, 'items': [[1800.0, 22.0], [2200.0, 17.0]]}, [34.0, 58.2]], ['sampled case 1', {'dow': 33923.0, 'doi': 39.1, 'ref': 19.3, 'c': 200.0, 'k': 45.3, 'lemac': 16.18, 'mac': 4.5, 'items': [[3739.0, 10.15]]}, [-131.96, 48.4]], ['sampled case 2', {'dow': 40403.0, 'doi': 39.1, 'ref': 21.4, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 44.8, 'lemac': 14.64, 'mac': 4.94, 'items': [[4674.0, 28.04]]}, [70.14, 148.2]], ['sampled case 3', {'dow': 30111.0, 'doi': 38.1, 'ref': 15.0, 'c': 200.0, 'k': 36.0, 'lemac': 15.26, 'mac': 4.8, 'items': [[5589.0, 17.22]]}, [100.14, 2.1]]], [['typical cabin and hold', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[3400.0, 14.0], [5000.0, 19.5], [1200.0, 24.0]]}, [49.1, 37.1]], ['empty operating aircraft', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': []}, [48.0, 36.3]], ['aft hold heavy', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[4000.0, 26.4]]}, [81.6, 54.7]], ['forward hold heavy', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[3500.0, 9.8]]}, [19.3, 20.6]], ['item at reference arm', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[10000.0, 18.0]]}, [48.0, 36.5]], ['different constants', {'dow': 36200.0, 'doi': 40.0, 'ref': 20.0, 'c': 500.0, 'k': 45.0, 'lemac': 18.0, 'mac': 3.2, 'items': [[1800.0, 22.0], [2200.0, 17.0]]}, [34.0, 58.2]], ['sampled case 1', {'dow': 40381.0, 'doi': 38.2, 'ref': 17.2, 'c': 200.0, 'k': 35.3, 'lemac': 17.91, 'mac': 3.25, 'items': [[1141.0, 14.25], [3763.0, 12.45]]}, [-68.0, -35.9]], ['sampled case 2', {'dow': 40833.0, 'doi': 53.7, 'ref': 21.5, 'c': 2000.0, 'k': 48.5, 'lemac': 17.83, 'mac': 3.22, 'items': [[4174.0, 19.61], [2120.0, 18.46], [4779.0, 27.55], [1973.0, 12.04]]}, [51.66, 117.6]], ['sampled case 3', {'dow': 33856.0, 'doi': 31.0, 'ref': 19.9, 'c': 200.0, 'k': 36.6, 'lemac': 18.08, 'mac': 4.82, 'items': []}, [31.0, 37.1]]], [['typical cabin and hold', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[3500.0, 14.0], [5000.0, 19.5], [1200.0, 24.0]]}, [48.7, 36.9]], ['empty operating aircraft', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': []}, [48.0, 36.3]], ['aft hold heavy', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[4000.0, 26.5]]}, [82.0, 54.9]], ['forward hold heavy', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[3500.0, 10.0]]}, [20.0, 21.0]], ['item at reference arm', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[12500.0, 18.0]]}, [48.0, 36.6]], ['different constants', {'dow': 36250.0, 'doi': 40.0, 'ref': 20.0, 'c': 500.0, 'k': 45.0, 'lemac': 18.0, 'mac': 3.2, 'items': [[1800.0, 22.0], [2200.0, 17.0]]}, [34.0, 58.2]], ['sampled case 1', {'dow': 34075.0, 'doi': 33.7, 'ref': 19.6, 'c': 2000.0, 'k': 36.1, 'lemac': 15.76, 'mac': 3.12, 'items': [[4801.0, 23.6], [3956.0, 16.47], [1810.0, 18.75], [1491.0, 15.01], [3514.0, 6.44]]}, [9.8, 89.1]], ['sampled case 2', {'dow': 33834.0, 'doi': 57.4, 'ref': 20.6, 'c': 500.0, 'k': 55.3, 'lemac': 15.75, 'mac': 3.95, 'items': [[3292.0, 11.8], [4846.0, 14.0], [3222.0, 25.52], [2090.0, 7.1], [168.0, 27.97]]}, [-86.76, 84.9]], ['sampled case 3', {'dow': 46921.0, 'doi': 51.0, 'ref': 17.8, 'c': 500.0, 'k': 52.3, 'lemac': 14.61, 'mac': 3.01, 'items': [[2487.0, 11.85], [4542.0, 19.68]]}, [38.48, 101.7]]]]
for label, args, expected in fixtures[N-1]:
    check(label, solve(args), expected)
print(json.dumps({"observations": observations, "passed": all(x["passed"] for x in observations)}, ensure_ascii=False))
raise SystemExit(0 if all(x["passed"] for x in observations) else 1)
Boundary fixtureActualExpectedOutcome
typical cabin and hold[32.3, 28.9][50.3, 37.6]Failed
empty operating aircraft[30.0, 25.6][48.0, 36.3]Failed
aft hold heavy[62.4, 44.2][80.4, 54.0]Failed
forward hold heavy[-0.8, 9.6][17.2, 19.5]Failed
item at reference arm[30.0, 26.3][48.0, 36.4]Failed
different constants[14.0, 50.4][34.0, 58.2]Failed
sampled case 1[99.9, 62.9][120.3, 68.4]Failed
sampled case 2[-274.74, 94.3][-254.74, 95.7]Failed
sampled case 3[24.7, 51.7][45.2, 83.3]Failed

SHA-256 / b30d8779b67467fe057ecafc5e0663dc27ca1ac6036109396c8f67a8a6c79108

3 / The verified repair

Exit 0
"""Failure Map reference implementation. Python standard library only."""
import json

N = 1
observations = []
def solve(x):
    ref, c, k = x['ref'], x['c'], x['k']
    w = x['dow']
    ti = x['doi']
    for iw, arm in x['items']:
        w += iw
        ti += iw * (arm - ref) / c
    cg = ref + (ti - k) * c / w
    pmac = (cg - x['lemac']) / x['mac'] * 100
    return [round(ti, 2), round(pmac, 1)]
def check(label, actual, expected):
    observations.append({"check": label, "actual": actual, "expected": expected, "passed": actual == expected})
fixtures = [[['typical cabin and hold', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[3100.0, 14.0], [5000.0, 19.5], [1200.0, 24.0]]}, [50.3, 37.6]], ['empty operating aircraft', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': []}, [48.0, 36.3]], ['aft hold heavy', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[4000.0, 26.1]]}, [80.4, 54.0]], ['forward hold heavy', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[3500.0, 9.2]]}, [17.2, 19.5]], ['item at reference arm', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[2500.0, 18.0]]}, [48.0, 36.4]], ['different constants', {'dow': 36050.0, 'doi': 40.0, 'ref': 20.0, 'c': 500.0, 'k': 45.0, 'lemac': 18.0, 'mac': 3.2, 'items': [[1800.0, 22.0], [2200.0, 17.0]]}, [34.0, 58.2]], ['sampled case 1', {'dow': 33485.0, 'doi': 37.0, 'ref': 20.4, 'c': 500.0, 'k': 44.4, 'lemac': 18.68, 'mac': 3.58, 'items': [[4603.0, 5.73], [2919.0, 25.41], [5509.0, 29.73], [5663.0, 28.02]]}, [120.3, 68.4]], ['sampled case 2', {'dow': 45884.0, 'doi': 51.2, 'ref': 20.0, 'c': 200.0, 'k': 57.4, 'lemac': 14.39, 'mac': 4.79, 'items': [[4694.0, 15.31], [4327.0, 9.7], [185.0, 15.41], [4752.0, 22.51], [992.0, 14.27]]}, [-254.74, 95.7]], ['sampled case 3', {'dow': 36007.0, 'doi': 45.2, 'ref': 20.5, 'c': 2000.0, 'k': 46.9, 'lemac': 17.4, 'mac': 3.61, 'items': []}, [45.2, 83.3]]], [['typical cabin and hold', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[3200.0, 14.0], [5000.0, 19.5], [1200.0, 24.0]]}, [49.9, 37.5]], ['empty operating aircraft', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': []}, [48.0, 36.3]], ['aft hold heavy', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[4000.0, 26.2]]}, [80.8, 54.2]], ['forward hold heavy', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[3500.0, 9.4]]}, [17.9, 19.9]], ['item at reference arm', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[5000.0, 18.0]]}, [48.0, 36.4]], ['different constants', {'dow': 36100.0, 'doi': 40.0, 'ref': 20.0, 'c': 500.0, 'k': 45.0, 'lemac': 18.0, 'mac': 3.2, 'items': [[1800.0, 22.0], [2200.0, 17.0]]}, [34.0, 58.2]], ['sampled case 1', {'dow': 41485.0, 'doi': 53.7, 'ref': 17.2, 'c': 500.0, 'k': 53.6, 'lemac': 14.91, 'mac': 4.7, 'items': [[323.0, 8.3], [3020.0, 17.98], [2440.0, 14.22]]}, [38.12, 45.2]], ['sampled case 2', {'dow': 36221.0, 'doi': 55.1, 'ref': 19.8, 'c': 2000.0, 'k': 56.4, 'lemac': 18.06, 'mac': 3.42, 'items': [[1053.0, 22.91]]}, [56.74, 51.4]], ['sampled case 3', {'dow': 36359.0, 'doi': 27.6, 'ref': 16.4, 'c': 200.0, 'k': 30.8, 'lemac': 14.16, 'mac': 3.79, 'items': [[2072.0, 5.02]]}, [-90.3, 42.5]]], [['typical cabin and hold', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[3300.0, 14.0], [5000.0, 19.5], [1200.0, 24.0]]}, [49.5, 37.3]], ['empty operating aircraft', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': []}, [48.0, 36.3]], ['aft hold heavy', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[4000.0, 26.3]]}, [81.2, 54.5]], ['forward hold heavy', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[3500.0, 9.6]]}, [18.6, 20.2]], ['item at reference arm', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[7500.0, 18.0]]}, [48.0, 36.5]], ['different constants', {'dow': 36150.0, 'doi': 40.0, 'ref': 20.0, 'c': 500.0, 'k': 45.0, 'lemac': 18.0, 'mac': 3.2, 'items': [[1800.0, 22.0], [2200.0, 17.0]]}, [34.0, 58.2]], ['sampled case 1', {'dow': 33923.0, 'doi': 39.1, 'ref': 19.3, 'c': 200.0, 'k': 45.3, 'lemac': 16.18, 'mac': 4.5, 'items': [[3739.0, 10.15]]}, [-131.96, 48.4]], ['sampled case 2', {'dow': 40403.0, 'doi': 39.1, 'ref': 21.4, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 44.8, 'lemac': 14.64, 'mac': 4.94, 'items': [[4674.0, 28.04]]}, [70.14, 148.2]], ['sampled case 3', {'dow': 30111.0, 'doi': 38.1, 'ref': 15.0, 'c': 200.0, 'k': 36.0, 'lemac': 15.26, 'mac': 4.8, 'items': [[5589.0, 17.22]]}, [100.14, 2.1]]], [['typical cabin and hold', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[3400.0, 14.0], [5000.0, 19.5], [1200.0, 24.0]]}, [49.1, 37.1]], ['empty operating aircraft', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': []}, [48.0, 36.3]], ['aft hold heavy', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[4000.0, 26.4]]}, [81.6, 54.7]], ['forward hold heavy', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[3500.0, 9.8]]}, [19.3, 20.6]], ['item at reference arm', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[10000.0, 18.0]]}, [48.0, 36.5]], ['different constants', {'dow': 36200.0, 'doi': 40.0, 'ref': 20.0, 'c': 500.0, 'k': 45.0, 'lemac': 18.0, 'mac': 3.2, 'items': [[1800.0, 22.0], [2200.0, 17.0]]}, [34.0, 58.2]], ['sampled case 1', {'dow': 40381.0, 'doi': 38.2, 'ref': 17.2, 'c': 200.0, 'k': 35.3, 'lemac': 17.91, 'mac': 3.25, 'items': [[1141.0, 14.25], [3763.0, 12.45]]}, [-68.0, -35.9]], ['sampled case 2', {'dow': 40833.0, 'doi': 53.7, 'ref': 21.5, 'c': 2000.0, 'k': 48.5, 'lemac': 17.83, 'mac': 3.22, 'items': [[4174.0, 19.61], [2120.0, 18.46], [4779.0, 27.55], [1973.0, 12.04]]}, [51.66, 117.6]], ['sampled case 3', {'dow': 33856.0, 'doi': 31.0, 'ref': 19.9, 'c': 200.0, 'k': 36.6, 'lemac': 18.08, 'mac': 4.82, 'items': []}, [31.0, 37.1]]], [['typical cabin and hold', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[3500.0, 14.0], [5000.0, 19.5], [1200.0, 24.0]]}, [48.7, 36.9]], ['empty operating aircraft', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': []}, [48.0, 36.3]], ['aft hold heavy', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[4000.0, 26.5]]}, [82.0, 54.9]], ['forward hold heavy', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[3500.0, 10.0]]}, [20.0, 21.0]], ['item at reference arm', {'dow': 42000.0, 'doi': 48.0, 'ref': 18.0, 'c': 1000.0, 'k': 50.0, 'lemac': 16.5, 'mac': 4.0, 'items': [[12500.0, 18.0]]}, [48.0, 36.6]], ['different constants', {'dow': 36250.0, 'doi': 40.0, 'ref': 20.0, 'c': 500.0, 'k': 45.0, 'lemac': 18.0, 'mac': 3.2, 'items': [[1800.0, 22.0], [2200.0, 17.0]]}, [34.0, 58.2]], ['sampled case 1', {'dow': 34075.0, 'doi': 33.7, 'ref': 19.6, 'c': 2000.0, 'k': 36.1, 'lemac': 15.76, 'mac': 3.12, 'items': [[4801.0, 23.6], [3956.0, 16.47], [1810.0, 18.75], [1491.0, 15.01], [3514.0, 6.44]]}, [9.8, 89.1]], ['sampled case 2', {'dow': 33834.0, 'doi': 57.4, 'ref': 20.6, 'c': 500.0, 'k': 55.3, 'lemac': 15.75, 'mac': 3.95, 'items': [[3292.0, 11.8], [4846.0, 14.0], [3222.0, 25.52], [2090.0, 7.1], [168.0, 27.97]]}, [-86.76, 84.9]], ['sampled case 3', {'dow': 46921.0, 'doi': 51.0, 'ref': 17.8, 'c': 500.0, 'k': 52.3, 'lemac': 14.61, 'mac': 3.01, 'items': [[2487.0, 11.85], [4542.0, 19.68]]}, [38.48, 101.7]]]]
for label, args, expected in fixtures[N-1]:
    check(label, solve(args), expected)
print(json.dumps({"observations": observations, "passed": all(x["passed"] for x in observations)}, ensure_ascii=False))
raise SystemExit(0 if all(x["passed"] for x in observations) else 1)
Boundary fixtureActualExpectedOutcome
typical cabin and hold[50.3, 37.6][50.3, 37.6]Passed
empty operating aircraft[48.0, 36.3][48.0, 36.3]Passed
aft hold heavy[80.4, 54.0][80.4, 54.0]Passed
forward hold heavy[17.2, 19.5][17.2, 19.5]Passed
item at reference arm[48.0, 36.4][48.0, 36.4]Passed
different constants[34.0, 58.2][34.0, 58.2]Passed
sampled case 1[120.3, 68.4][120.3, 68.4]Passed
sampled case 2[-254.74, 95.7][-254.74, 95.7]Passed
sampled case 3[45.2, 83.3][45.2, 83.3]Passed

SHA-256 / 29e9cc4a8fe4ede3b8326c94a7b85ee7eaa307ffd8a5b9bb462fd3ae70532e71

Verification & scope

A deterministic toy loading model with stipulated constants; it is not an approved aircraft flight manual procedure and makes no claim of regulatory conformance. This reproducer isolates one failure mechanism. Results cover the supplied fixtures. Variants within a family share a test contract and should remain grouped when constructing evaluation splits. Related mechanisms with a shared evaluation_group must also remain together; these controlled models are not independent production incidents.

Observations recorded using Python 3.12.14 at 2026-09-29T14:47:38.405447+00:00.

Case digest / 4e9ad37bdcff25a15a55b51a6f8071143ff3d635782a632e3dec7e796bb3492c