FAILURE MAP
← Case archive

FA-58216 / Double-entry ledger accounting / Open access

Journal void and reversal linkage: failed void side effect · case 01

A rejected void still leaves the target entry marked voided.

Verified by executionVariant 1 · 7 checks per implementationDownload source bundle ↓JSON ↗

ROOT CAUSE

The target status is changed before the reversal id collision is reported.

VERIFIED REPAIR

Change no state when a void is rejected.

Unsuccessful approach: Zeroing the original keeps the balance plausible but still mutates the entry and its status.

Case contract

x = [['post', id, amount] | ['void', target_id, reversal_id] | other]. Posting an existing id is an error 'duplicate'. Voiding needs a known target ('unknown'), whose status is 'posted' ('not_voidable' for voided entries and reversals) and an unused reversal id ('duplicate'), checked in that order. A void marks the target 'voided' and creates a 'reversal' entry with the negated amount. Other commands give 'bad_command'. Return {'status', 'balance': sum of all amounts, 'errors': [[index, reason]]}.

Why this case matters

Ledger software must keep debits equal to credits and apply normal-balance, period and cutoff rules exactly; small sign or boundary slips silently misstate financial statements.

1 / The failure

Exit 1
"""Failure Map reference implementation. Python standard library only."""
import json

N = 1
observations = []
def solve(x):
    status = {}
    amounts = {}
    errors = []
    for i, cmd in enumerate(x):
        if cmd[0] == 'post':
            _, eid, amt = cmd
            if eid in status:
                errors.append([i, 'duplicate'])
                continue
            status[eid] = 'posted'
            amounts[eid] = amt
        elif cmd[0] == 'void':
            _, target, new = cmd
            if target not in status:
                errors.append([i, 'unknown'])
            elif status[target] != 'posted':
                errors.append([i, 'not_voidable'])
            elif new in status:
                status[target] = 'voided'
                errors.append([i, 'duplicate'])
            else:
                status[target] = 'voided'
                status[new] = 'reversal'
                amounts[new] = -amounts[target]
        else:
            errors.append([i, 'bad_command'])
    return {'status': status, 'balance': sum(amounts.values()), 'errors': errors}
def check(label, actual, expected):
    observations.append({"check": label, "actual": actual, "expected": expected, "passed": actual == expected})
fixtures = [[['regression: failed void side effect', [['post', 'R1', -40], ['post', 'R1', 100], ['post', 'D', 999], ['edit', 'A', 5], ['void', 'R1', 'D'], ['void', 'R1', 'R2'], ['post', 'D', 999], ['void', 'R1', 'R1']], {'status': {'R1': 'voided', 'D': 'posted', 'R2': 'reversal'}, 'balance': 999, 'errors': [[1, 'duplicate'], [3, 'bad_command'], [4, 'duplicate'], [6, 'duplicate'], [7, 'not_voidable']]}], ['control 1', [['edit', 'A', 5], ['post', 'C', 999], ['void', 'C', 'R2'], ['void', 'R3', 'D']], {'status': {'C': 'voided', 'R2': 'reversal'}, 'balance': 0, 'errors': [[0, 'bad_command'], [3, 'unknown']]}], ['control 2', [['post', 'C', 250], ['edit', 'A', 5], ['edit', 'A', 5], ['void', 'R1', 'D']], {'status': {'C': 'posted'}, 'balance': 250, 'errors': [[1, 'bad_command'], [2, 'bad_command'], [3, 'unknown']]}], ['control 3', [['void', 'R2', 'D'], ['post', 'D', 999], ['post', 'D', 999], ['post', 'R1', 100], ['void', 'A', 'D']], {'status': {'D': 'posted', 'R1': 'posted'}, 'balance': 1099, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [2, 'duplicate'], [4, 'unknown']]}], ['control 4', [['void', 'R3', 'R2'], ['void', 'R2', 'D'], ['void', 'R1', 'R2'], ['post', 'D', 250], ['void', 'R2', 'R1'], ['void', 'R1', 'R2'], ['void', 'D', 'R3'], ['post', 'R1', 100]], {'status': {'D': 'voided', 'R3': 'reversal', 'R1': 'posted'}, 'balance': 100, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [2, 'unknown'], [4, 'unknown'], [5, 'unknown']]}], ['control 5', [['void', 'C', 'R1'], ['void', 'R1', 'R2'], ['edit', 'A', 5], ['void', 'C', 'R1'], ['void', 'R3', 'R1'], ['post', 'D', 999]], {'status': {'D': 'posted'}, 'balance': 999, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [2, 'bad_command'], [3, 'unknown'], [4, 'unknown']]}], ['control 6', [['post', 'A', 999], ['post', 'D', -40], ['void', 'R1', 'R1'], ['post', 'B', 999], ['void', 'B', 'R3'], ['post', 'R1', 999], ['post', 'B', 250]], {'status': {'A': 'posted', 'D': 'posted', 'B': 'voided', 'R3': 'reversal', 'R1': 'posted'}, 'balance': 1958, 'errors': [[2, 'unknown'], [6, 'duplicate']]}]], [['regression: failed void side effect', [['post', 'B', 250], ['void', 'D', 'R3'], ['post', 'D', -40], ['post', 'A', -40], ['void', 'R3', 'R1'], ['void', 'R2', 'R3'], ['post', 'R1', -40], ['void', 'B', 'R1']], {'status': {'B': 'posted', 'D': 'posted', 'A': 'posted', 'R1': 'posted'}, 'balance': 130, 'errors': [[1, 'unknown'], [4, 'unknown'], [5, 'unknown'], [7, 'duplicate']]}], ['control 1', [['post', 'B', 250], ['post', 'C', 250], ['edit', 'A', 5], ['post', 'B', 250], ['post', 'B', 100]], {'status': {'B': 'posted', 'C': 'posted'}, 'balance': 500, 'errors': [[2, 'bad_command'], [3, 'duplicate'], [4, 'duplicate']]}], ['control 2', [['post', 'R1', -40], ['post', 'B', 250], ['post', 'C', 250], ['void', 'R2', 'R3']], {'status': {'R1': 'posted', 'B': 'posted', 'C': 'posted'}, 'balance': 460, 'errors': [[3, 'unknown']]}], ['control 3', [['post', 'A', 999], ['void', 'R1', 'R3'], ['void', 'R2', 'R2'], ['post', 'R1', 999]], {'status': {'A': 'posted', 'R1': 'posted'}, 'balance': 1998, 'errors': [[1, 'unknown'], [2, 'unknown']]}], ['control 4', [['void', 'C', 'D'], ['void', 'D', 'R1'], ['void', 'R3', 'D'], ['post', 'A', -40], ['post', 'D', 999], ['post', 'C', -40], ['void', 'R1', 'R3']], {'status': {'A': 'posted', 'D': 'posted', 'C': 'posted'}, 'balance': 919, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [2, 'unknown'], [6, 'unknown']]}], ['control 5', [['void', 'R1', 'R3'], ['void', 'C', 'D'], ['void', 'B', 'D'], ['post', 'R1', 250], ['void', 'R2', 'D'], ['post', 'D', -40], ['void', 'C', 'D']], {'status': {'R1': 'posted', 'D': 'posted'}, 'balance': 210, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [2, 'unknown'], [4, 'unknown'], [6, 'unknown']]}], ['control 6', [['post', 'A', 250], ['post', 'A', 100], ['post', 'D', 999]], {'status': {'A': 'posted', 'D': 'posted'}, 'balance': 1249, 'errors': [[1, 'duplicate']]}]], [['regression: failed void side effect', [['void', 'R3', 'R1'], ['post', 'D', -40], ['void', 'R3', 'R1'], ['post', 'R1', 100], ['post', 'A', 250], ['void', 'R1', 'R3'], ['void', 'A', 'D'], ['void', 'R1', 'R1']], {'status': {'D': 'posted', 'R1': 'voided', 'A': 'posted', 'R3': 'reversal'}, 'balance': 210, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [2, 'unknown'], [6, 'duplicate'], [7, 'not_voidable']]}], ['control 1', [['void', 'R1', 'R3'], ['void', 'A', 'R3'], ['void', 'R3', 'R1']], {'status': {}, 'balance': 0, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [2, 'unknown']]}], ['control 2', [['void', 'C', 'R3'], ['void', 'R1', 'R3'], ['void', 'R2', 'R1'], ['void', 'R1', 'R1'], ['void', 'C', 'D'], ['void', 'A', 'R1'], ['post', 'D', 999]], {'status': {'D': 'posted'}, 'balance': 999, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [2, 'unknown'], [3, 'unknown'], [4, 'unknown'], [5, 'unknown']]}], ['control 3', [['post', 'D', -40], ['void', 'R3', 'R1'], ['post', 'B', 100], ['post', 'R1', 250], ['void', 'C', 'D'], ['post', 'A', 999], ['void', 'R2', 'R2']], {'status': {'D': 'posted', 'B': 'posted', 'R1': 'posted', 'A': 'posted'}, 'balance': 1309, 'errors': [[1, 'unknown'], [4, 'unknown'], [6, 'unknown']]}], ['control 4', [['edit', 'A', 5], ['post', 'R1', -40], ['post', 'C', 100], ['post', 'C', 100], ['post', 'R1', 100], ['void', 'R2', 'D'], ['post', 'B', -40]], {'status': {'R1': 'posted', 'C': 'posted', 'B': 'posted'}, 'balance': 20, 'errors': [[0, 'bad_command'], [3, 'duplicate'], [4, 'duplicate'], [5, 'unknown']]}], ['control 5', [['post', 'C', 250], ['post', 'B', 999], ['void', 'C', 'D'], ['post', 'A', -40], ['void', 'R3', 'R1'], ['void', 'R2', 'R3'], ['void', 'R2', 'R3'], ['void', 'B', 'R1']], {'status': {'C': 'voided', 'B': 'voided', 'D': 'reversal', 'A': 'posted', 'R1': 'reversal'}, 'balance': -40, 'errors': [[4, 'unknown'], [5, 'unknown'], [6, 'unknown']]}], ['control 6', [['post', 'B', 999], ['void', 'R3', 'R1'], ['void', 'D', 'R3'], ['post', 'C', 100], ['post', 'D', 999]], {'status': {'B': 'posted', 'C': 'posted', 'D': 'posted'}, 'balance': 2098, 'errors': [[1, 'unknown'], [2, 'unknown']]}]], [['regression: failed void side effect', [['post', 'C', 999], ['void', 'R2', 'R1'], ['post', 'D', 999], ['post', 'A', 999], ['void', 'D', 'D'], ['post', 'B', -40], ['post', 'B', 999]], {'status': {'C': 'posted', 'D': 'posted', 'A': 'posted', 'B': 'posted'}, 'balance': 2957, 'errors': [[1, 'unknown'], [4, 'duplicate'], [6, 'duplicate']]}], ['control 1', [['void', 'A', 'R1'], ['void', 'A', 'R1'], ['void', 'B', 'R3'], ['post', 'C', 100], ['post', 'B', -40], ['edit', 'A', 5], ['void', 'R2', 'D']], {'status': {'C': 'posted', 'B': 'posted'}, 'balance': 60, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [2, 'unknown'], [5, 'bad_command'], [6, 'unknown']]}], ['control 2', [['void', 'D', 'R1'], ['post', 'D', -40], ['post', 'A', 100], ['void', 'A', 'R1'], ['void', 'A', 'R3']], {'status': {'D': 'posted', 'A': 'voided', 'R1': 'reversal'}, 'balance': -40, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [4, 'not_voidable']]}], ['control 3', [['void', 'D', 'R2'], ['void', 'R3', 'R3'], ['post', 'B', 250], ['void', 'D', 'D'], ['post', 'C', 999], ['post', 'B', -40]], {'status': {'B': 'posted', 'C': 'posted'}, 'balance': 1249, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [3, 'unknown'], [5, 'duplicate']]}], ['control 4', [['post', 'R1', -40], ['void', 'D', 'R1'], ['post', 'A', 250], ['void', 'R1', 'D']], {'status': {'R1': 'voided', 'A': 'posted', 'D': 'reversal'}, 'balance': 250, 'errors': [[1, 'unknown']]}], ['control 5', [['edit', 'A', 5], ['edit', 'A', 5], ['post', 'D', 100], ['post', 'B', 999]], {'status': {'D': 'posted', 'B': 'posted'}, 'balance': 1099, 'errors': [[0, 'bad_command'], [1, 'bad_command']]}], ['control 6', [['post', 'R1', 250], ['void', 'R1', 'D'], ['void', 'R1', 'R3'], ['void', 'R1', 'R3'], ['void', 'D', 'D'], ['post', 'B', -40], ['void', 'B', 'R2'], ['post', 'C', -40]], {'status': {'R1': 'voided', 'D': 'reversal', 'B': 'voided', 'R2': 'reversal', 'C': 'posted'}, 'balance': -40, 'errors': [[2, 'not_voidable'], [3, 'not_voidable'], [4, 'not_voidable']]}]], [['regression: failed void side effect', [['post', 'D', 100], ['void', 'B', 'R3'], ['post', 'A', 999], ['post', 'A', -40], ['void', 'D', 'D'], ['void', 'R1', 'R3']], {'status': {'D': 'posted', 'A': 'posted'}, 'balance': 1099, 'errors': [[1, 'unknown'], [3, 'duplicate'], [4, 'duplicate'], [5, 'unknown']]}], ['control 1', [['void', 'R2', 'R1'], ['void', 'B', 'D'], ['post', 'C', 250]], {'status': {'C': 'posted'}, 'balance': 250, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown']]}], ['control 2', [['void', 'A', 'R1'], ['post', 'A', -40], ['post', 'A', -40], ['post', 'A', 999], ['void', 'R1', 'R2']], {'status': {'A': 'posted'}, 'balance': -40, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [2, 'duplicate'], [3, 'duplicate'], [4, 'unknown']]}], ['control 3', [['post', 'B', 250], ['post', 'D', 100], ['post', 'A', 999], ['post', 'D', -40]], {'status': {'B': 'posted', 'D': 'posted', 'A': 'posted'}, 'balance': 1349, 'errors': [[3, 'duplicate']]}], ['control 4', [['void', 'C', 'R2'], ['void', 'B', 'R3'], ['void', 'R1', 'R2'], ['void', 'D', 'D'], ['void', 'R3', 'R2'], ['post', 'C', 250], ['post', 'A', 999], ['post', 'R1', 100]], {'status': {'C': 'posted', 'A': 'posted', 'R1': 'posted'}, 'balance': 1349, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [2, 'unknown'], [3, 'unknown'], [4, 'unknown']]}], ['control 5', [['void', 'R1', 'R3'], ['post', 'C', 999], ['post', 'R1', -40], ['post', 'D', 999], ['post', 'A', 250], ['post', 'B', 250], ['void', 'R2', 'D']], {'status': {'C': 'posted', 'R1': 'posted', 'D': 'posted', 'A': 'posted', 'B': 'posted'}, 'balance': 2458, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [6, 'unknown']]}], ['control 6', [['void', 'C', 'R1'], ['void', 'R1', 'R1'], ['void', 'R1', 'D'], ['post', 'C', 999], ['void', 'R2', 'D'], ['void', 'R2', 'D'], ['void', 'C', 'R2']], {'status': {'C': 'voided', 'R2': 'reversal'}, 'balance': 0, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [2, 'unknown'], [4, 'unknown'], [5, 'unknown']]}]]]
for label, args, expected in fixtures[N-1]:
    try:
        actual = solve(args)
    except Exception as exc:
        actual = 'raised ' + type(exc).__name__
    check(label, actual, expected)
print(json.dumps({"observations": observations, "passed": all(x["passed"] for x in observations)}, ensure_ascii=False))
raise SystemExit(0 if all(x["passed"] for x in observations) else 1)
Boundary fixtureActualExpectedOutcome
regression: failed void side effect{'balance': 959, 'errors': [[1, 'duplicate'], [3, 'bad_command'], [4, 'duplicate'], [5, 'not_voidable'], [6, 'duplicate'], [7, 'not_voidable']], 'status': {'D': 'posted', 'R1': 'voided'}}{'balance': 999, 'errors': [[1, 'duplicate'], [3, 'bad_command'], [4, 'duplicate'], [6, 'duplicate'], [7, 'not_voidable']], 'status': {'D': 'posted', 'R1': 'voided', 'R2': 'reversal'}}Failed
control 1{'balance': 0, 'errors': [[0, 'bad_command'], [3, 'unknown']], 'status': {'C': 'voided', 'R2': 'reversal'}}{'balance': 0, 'errors': [[0, 'bad_command'], [3, 'unknown']], 'status': {'C': 'voided', 'R2': 'reversal'}}Passed
control 2{'balance': 250, 'errors': [[1, 'bad_command'], [2, 'bad_command'], [3, 'unknown']], 'status': {'C': 'posted'}}{'balance': 250, 'errors': [[1, 'bad_command'], [2, 'bad_command'], [3, 'unknown']], 'status': {'C': 'posted'}}Passed
control 3{'balance': 1099, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [2, 'duplicate'], [4, 'unknown']], 'status': {'D': 'posted', 'R1': 'posted'}}{'balance': 1099, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [2, 'duplicate'], [4, 'unknown']], 'status': {'D': 'posted', 'R1': 'posted'}}Passed
control 4{'balance': 100, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [2, 'unknown'], [4, 'unknown'], [5, 'unknown']], 'status': {'D': 'voided', 'R1': 'posted', 'R3': 'reversal'}}{'balance': 100, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [2, 'unknown'], [4, 'unknown'], [5, 'unknown']], 'status': {'D': 'voided', 'R1': 'posted', 'R3': 'reversal'}}Passed
control 5{'balance': 999, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [2, 'bad_command'], [3, 'unknown'], [4, 'unknown']], 'status': {'D': 'posted'}}{'balance': 999, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [2, 'bad_command'], [3, 'unknown'], [4, 'unknown']], 'status': {'D': 'posted'}}Passed
control 6{'balance': 1958, 'errors': [[2, 'unknown'], [6, 'duplicate']], 'status': {'A': 'posted', 'B': 'voided', 'D': 'posted', 'R1': 'posted', 'R3': 'reversal'}}{'balance': 1958, 'errors': [[2, 'unknown'], [6, 'duplicate']], 'status': {'A': 'posted', 'B': 'voided', 'D': 'posted', 'R1': 'posted', 'R3': 'reversal'}}Passed

SHA-256 / 905e9f827487ab4dc4f9617c57b0bb84c3a8dc134738c5b576bcecb05eaa9644

2 / The unsuccessful fix

Exit 1
"""Failure Map reference implementation. Python standard library only."""
import json

N = 1
observations = []
def solve(x):
    status = {}
    amounts = {}
    errors = []
    for i, cmd in enumerate(x):
        if cmd[0] == 'post':
            _, eid, amt = cmd
            if eid in status:
                errors.append([i, 'duplicate'])
                continue
            status[eid] = 'posted'
            amounts[eid] = amt
        elif cmd[0] == 'void':
            _, target, new = cmd
            if target not in status:
                errors.append([i, 'unknown'])
            elif status[target] != 'posted':
                errors.append([i, 'not_voidable'])
            elif new in status:
                status[target] = 'voided'
                amounts[target] = 0
                errors.append([i, 'duplicate'])
            else:
                status[target] = 'voided'
                status[new] = 'reversal'
                amounts[new] = -amounts[target]
        else:
            errors.append([i, 'bad_command'])
    return {'status': status, 'balance': sum(amounts.values()), 'errors': errors}
def check(label, actual, expected):
    observations.append({"check": label, "actual": actual, "expected": expected, "passed": actual == expected})
fixtures = [[['regression: failed void side effect', [['post', 'R1', -40], ['post', 'R1', 100], ['post', 'D', 999], ['edit', 'A', 5], ['void', 'R1', 'D'], ['void', 'R1', 'R2'], ['post', 'D', 999], ['void', 'R1', 'R1']], {'status': {'R1': 'voided', 'D': 'posted', 'R2': 'reversal'}, 'balance': 999, 'errors': [[1, 'duplicate'], [3, 'bad_command'], [4, 'duplicate'], [6, 'duplicate'], [7, 'not_voidable']]}], ['control 1', [['edit', 'A', 5], ['post', 'C', 999], ['void', 'C', 'R2'], ['void', 'R3', 'D']], {'status': {'C': 'voided', 'R2': 'reversal'}, 'balance': 0, 'errors': [[0, 'bad_command'], [3, 'unknown']]}], ['control 2', [['post', 'C', 250], ['edit', 'A', 5], ['edit', 'A', 5], ['void', 'R1', 'D']], {'status': {'C': 'posted'}, 'balance': 250, 'errors': [[1, 'bad_command'], [2, 'bad_command'], [3, 'unknown']]}], ['control 3', [['void', 'R2', 'D'], ['post', 'D', 999], ['post', 'D', 999], ['post', 'R1', 100], ['void', 'A', 'D']], {'status': {'D': 'posted', 'R1': 'posted'}, 'balance': 1099, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [2, 'duplicate'], [4, 'unknown']]}], ['control 4', [['void', 'R3', 'R2'], ['void', 'R2', 'D'], ['void', 'R1', 'R2'], ['post', 'D', 250], ['void', 'R2', 'R1'], ['void', 'R1', 'R2'], ['void', 'D', 'R3'], ['post', 'R1', 100]], {'status': {'D': 'voided', 'R3': 'reversal', 'R1': 'posted'}, 'balance': 100, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [2, 'unknown'], [4, 'unknown'], [5, 'unknown']]}], ['control 5', [['void', 'C', 'R1'], ['void', 'R1', 'R2'], ['edit', 'A', 5], ['void', 'C', 'R1'], ['void', 'R3', 'R1'], ['post', 'D', 999]], {'status': {'D': 'posted'}, 'balance': 999, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [2, 'bad_command'], [3, 'unknown'], [4, 'unknown']]}], ['control 6', [['post', 'A', 999], ['post', 'D', -40], ['void', 'R1', 'R1'], ['post', 'B', 999], ['void', 'B', 'R3'], ['post', 'R1', 999], ['post', 'B', 250]], {'status': {'A': 'posted', 'D': 'posted', 'B': 'voided', 'R3': 'reversal', 'R1': 'posted'}, 'balance': 1958, 'errors': [[2, 'unknown'], [6, 'duplicate']]}]], [['regression: failed void side effect', [['post', 'B', 250], ['void', 'D', 'R3'], ['post', 'D', -40], ['post', 'A', -40], ['void', 'R3', 'R1'], ['void', 'R2', 'R3'], ['post', 'R1', -40], ['void', 'B', 'R1']], {'status': {'B': 'posted', 'D': 'posted', 'A': 'posted', 'R1': 'posted'}, 'balance': 130, 'errors': [[1, 'unknown'], [4, 'unknown'], [5, 'unknown'], [7, 'duplicate']]}], ['control 1', [['post', 'B', 250], ['post', 'C', 250], ['edit', 'A', 5], ['post', 'B', 250], ['post', 'B', 100]], {'status': {'B': 'posted', 'C': 'posted'}, 'balance': 500, 'errors': [[2, 'bad_command'], [3, 'duplicate'], [4, 'duplicate']]}], ['control 2', [['post', 'R1', -40], ['post', 'B', 250], ['post', 'C', 250], ['void', 'R2', 'R3']], {'status': {'R1': 'posted', 'B': 'posted', 'C': 'posted'}, 'balance': 460, 'errors': [[3, 'unknown']]}], ['control 3', [['post', 'A', 999], ['void', 'R1', 'R3'], ['void', 'R2', 'R2'], ['post', 'R1', 999]], {'status': {'A': 'posted', 'R1': 'posted'}, 'balance': 1998, 'errors': [[1, 'unknown'], [2, 'unknown']]}], ['control 4', [['void', 'C', 'D'], ['void', 'D', 'R1'], ['void', 'R3', 'D'], ['post', 'A', -40], ['post', 'D', 999], ['post', 'C', -40], ['void', 'R1', 'R3']], {'status': {'A': 'posted', 'D': 'posted', 'C': 'posted'}, 'balance': 919, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [2, 'unknown'], [6, 'unknown']]}], ['control 5', [['void', 'R1', 'R3'], ['void', 'C', 'D'], ['void', 'B', 'D'], ['post', 'R1', 250], ['void', 'R2', 'D'], ['post', 'D', -40], ['void', 'C', 'D']], {'status': {'R1': 'posted', 'D': 'posted'}, 'balance': 210, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [2, 'unknown'], [4, 'unknown'], [6, 'unknown']]}], ['control 6', [['post', 'A', 250], ['post', 'A', 100], ['post', 'D', 999]], {'status': {'A': 'posted', 'D': 'posted'}, 'balance': 1249, 'errors': [[1, 'duplicate']]}]], [['regression: failed void side effect', [['void', 'R3', 'R1'], ['post', 'D', -40], ['void', 'R3', 'R1'], ['post', 'R1', 100], ['post', 'A', 250], ['void', 'R1', 'R3'], ['void', 'A', 'D'], ['void', 'R1', 'R1']], {'status': {'D': 'posted', 'R1': 'voided', 'A': 'posted', 'R3': 'reversal'}, 'balance': 210, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [2, 'unknown'], [6, 'duplicate'], [7, 'not_voidable']]}], ['control 1', [['void', 'R1', 'R3'], ['void', 'A', 'R3'], ['void', 'R3', 'R1']], {'status': {}, 'balance': 0, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [2, 'unknown']]}], ['control 2', [['void', 'C', 'R3'], ['void', 'R1', 'R3'], ['void', 'R2', 'R1'], ['void', 'R1', 'R1'], ['void', 'C', 'D'], ['void', 'A', 'R1'], ['post', 'D', 999]], {'status': {'D': 'posted'}, 'balance': 999, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [2, 'unknown'], [3, 'unknown'], [4, 'unknown'], [5, 'unknown']]}], ['control 3', [['post', 'D', -40], ['void', 'R3', 'R1'], ['post', 'B', 100], ['post', 'R1', 250], ['void', 'C', 'D'], ['post', 'A', 999], ['void', 'R2', 'R2']], {'status': {'D': 'posted', 'B': 'posted', 'R1': 'posted', 'A': 'posted'}, 'balance': 1309, 'errors': [[1, 'unknown'], [4, 'unknown'], [6, 'unknown']]}], ['control 4', [['edit', 'A', 5], ['post', 'R1', -40], ['post', 'C', 100], ['post', 'C', 100], ['post', 'R1', 100], ['void', 'R2', 'D'], ['post', 'B', -40]], {'status': {'R1': 'posted', 'C': 'posted', 'B': 'posted'}, 'balance': 20, 'errors': [[0, 'bad_command'], [3, 'duplicate'], [4, 'duplicate'], [5, 'unknown']]}], ['control 5', [['post', 'C', 250], ['post', 'B', 999], ['void', 'C', 'D'], ['post', 'A', -40], ['void', 'R3', 'R1'], ['void', 'R2', 'R3'], ['void', 'R2', 'R3'], ['void', 'B', 'R1']], {'status': {'C': 'voided', 'B': 'voided', 'D': 'reversal', 'A': 'posted', 'R1': 'reversal'}, 'balance': -40, 'errors': [[4, 'unknown'], [5, 'unknown'], [6, 'unknown']]}], ['control 6', [['post', 'B', 999], ['void', 'R3', 'R1'], ['void', 'D', 'R3'], ['post', 'C', 100], ['post', 'D', 999]], {'status': {'B': 'posted', 'C': 'posted', 'D': 'posted'}, 'balance': 2098, 'errors': [[1, 'unknown'], [2, 'unknown']]}]], [['regression: failed void side effect', [['post', 'C', 999], ['void', 'R2', 'R1'], ['post', 'D', 999], ['post', 'A', 999], ['void', 'D', 'D'], ['post', 'B', -40], ['post', 'B', 999]], {'status': {'C': 'posted', 'D': 'posted', 'A': 'posted', 'B': 'posted'}, 'balance': 2957, 'errors': [[1, 'unknown'], [4, 'duplicate'], [6, 'duplicate']]}], ['control 1', [['void', 'A', 'R1'], ['void', 'A', 'R1'], ['void', 'B', 'R3'], ['post', 'C', 100], ['post', 'B', -40], ['edit', 'A', 5], ['void', 'R2', 'D']], {'status': {'C': 'posted', 'B': 'posted'}, 'balance': 60, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [2, 'unknown'], [5, 'bad_command'], [6, 'unknown']]}], ['control 2', [['void', 'D', 'R1'], ['post', 'D', -40], ['post', 'A', 100], ['void', 'A', 'R1'], ['void', 'A', 'R3']], {'status': {'D': 'posted', 'A': 'voided', 'R1': 'reversal'}, 'balance': -40, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [4, 'not_voidable']]}], ['control 3', [['void', 'D', 'R2'], ['void', 'R3', 'R3'], ['post', 'B', 250], ['void', 'D', 'D'], ['post', 'C', 999], ['post', 'B', -40]], {'status': {'B': 'posted', 'C': 'posted'}, 'balance': 1249, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [3, 'unknown'], [5, 'duplicate']]}], ['control 4', [['post', 'R1', -40], ['void', 'D', 'R1'], ['post', 'A', 250], ['void', 'R1', 'D']], {'status': {'R1': 'voided', 'A': 'posted', 'D': 'reversal'}, 'balance': 250, 'errors': [[1, 'unknown']]}], ['control 5', [['edit', 'A', 5], ['edit', 'A', 5], ['post', 'D', 100], ['post', 'B', 999]], {'status': {'D': 'posted', 'B': 'posted'}, 'balance': 1099, 'errors': [[0, 'bad_command'], [1, 'bad_command']]}], ['control 6', [['post', 'R1', 250], ['void', 'R1', 'D'], ['void', 'R1', 'R3'], ['void', 'R1', 'R3'], ['void', 'D', 'D'], ['post', 'B', -40], ['void', 'B', 'R2'], ['post', 'C', -40]], {'status': {'R1': 'voided', 'D': 'reversal', 'B': 'voided', 'R2': 'reversal', 'C': 'posted'}, 'balance': -40, 'errors': [[2, 'not_voidable'], [3, 'not_voidable'], [4, 'not_voidable']]}]], [['regression: failed void side effect', [['post', 'D', 100], ['void', 'B', 'R3'], ['post', 'A', 999], ['post', 'A', -40], ['void', 'D', 'D'], ['void', 'R1', 'R3']], {'status': {'D': 'posted', 'A': 'posted'}, 'balance': 1099, 'errors': [[1, 'unknown'], [3, 'duplicate'], [4, 'duplicate'], [5, 'unknown']]}], ['control 1', [['void', 'R2', 'R1'], ['void', 'B', 'D'], ['post', 'C', 250]], {'status': {'C': 'posted'}, 'balance': 250, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown']]}], ['control 2', [['void', 'A', 'R1'], ['post', 'A', -40], ['post', 'A', -40], ['post', 'A', 999], ['void', 'R1', 'R2']], {'status': {'A': 'posted'}, 'balance': -40, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [2, 'duplicate'], [3, 'duplicate'], [4, 'unknown']]}], ['control 3', [['post', 'B', 250], ['post', 'D', 100], ['post', 'A', 999], ['post', 'D', -40]], {'status': {'B': 'posted', 'D': 'posted', 'A': 'posted'}, 'balance': 1349, 'errors': [[3, 'duplicate']]}], ['control 4', [['void', 'C', 'R2'], ['void', 'B', 'R3'], ['void', 'R1', 'R2'], ['void', 'D', 'D'], ['void', 'R3', 'R2'], ['post', 'C', 250], ['post', 'A', 999], ['post', 'R1', 100]], {'status': {'C': 'posted', 'A': 'posted', 'R1': 'posted'}, 'balance': 1349, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [2, 'unknown'], [3, 'unknown'], [4, 'unknown']]}], ['control 5', [['void', 'R1', 'R3'], ['post', 'C', 999], ['post', 'R1', -40], ['post', 'D', 999], ['post', 'A', 250], ['post', 'B', 250], ['void', 'R2', 'D']], {'status': {'C': 'posted', 'R1': 'posted', 'D': 'posted', 'A': 'posted', 'B': 'posted'}, 'balance': 2458, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [6, 'unknown']]}], ['control 6', [['void', 'C', 'R1'], ['void', 'R1', 'R1'], ['void', 'R1', 'D'], ['post', 'C', 999], ['void', 'R2', 'D'], ['void', 'R2', 'D'], ['void', 'C', 'R2']], {'status': {'C': 'voided', 'R2': 'reversal'}, 'balance': 0, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [2, 'unknown'], [4, 'unknown'], [5, 'unknown']]}]]]
for label, args, expected in fixtures[N-1]:
    try:
        actual = solve(args)
    except Exception as exc:
        actual = 'raised ' + type(exc).__name__
    check(label, actual, expected)
print(json.dumps({"observations": observations, "passed": all(x["passed"] for x in observations)}, ensure_ascii=False))
raise SystemExit(0 if all(x["passed"] for x in observations) else 1)
Boundary fixtureActualExpectedOutcome
regression: failed void side effect{'balance': 999, 'errors': [[1, 'duplicate'], [3, 'bad_command'], [4, 'duplicate'], [5, 'not_voidable'], [6, 'duplicate'], [7, 'not_voidable']], 'status': {'D': 'posted', 'R1': 'voided'}}{'balance': 999, 'errors': [[1, 'duplicate'], [3, 'bad_command'], [4, 'duplicate'], [6, 'duplicate'], [7, 'not_voidable']], 'status': {'D': 'posted', 'R1': 'voided', 'R2': 'reversal'}}Failed
control 1{'balance': 0, 'errors': [[0, 'bad_command'], [3, 'unknown']], 'status': {'C': 'voided', 'R2': 'reversal'}}{'balance': 0, 'errors': [[0, 'bad_command'], [3, 'unknown']], 'status': {'C': 'voided', 'R2': 'reversal'}}Passed
control 2{'balance': 250, 'errors': [[1, 'bad_command'], [2, 'bad_command'], [3, 'unknown']], 'status': {'C': 'posted'}}{'balance': 250, 'errors': [[1, 'bad_command'], [2, 'bad_command'], [3, 'unknown']], 'status': {'C': 'posted'}}Passed
control 3{'balance': 1099, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [2, 'duplicate'], [4, 'unknown']], 'status': {'D': 'posted', 'R1': 'posted'}}{'balance': 1099, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [2, 'duplicate'], [4, 'unknown']], 'status': {'D': 'posted', 'R1': 'posted'}}Passed
control 4{'balance': 100, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [2, 'unknown'], [4, 'unknown'], [5, 'unknown']], 'status': {'D': 'voided', 'R1': 'posted', 'R3': 'reversal'}}{'balance': 100, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [2, 'unknown'], [4, 'unknown'], [5, 'unknown']], 'status': {'D': 'voided', 'R1': 'posted', 'R3': 'reversal'}}Passed
control 5{'balance': 999, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [2, 'bad_command'], [3, 'unknown'], [4, 'unknown']], 'status': {'D': 'posted'}}{'balance': 999, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [2, 'bad_command'], [3, 'unknown'], [4, 'unknown']], 'status': {'D': 'posted'}}Passed
control 6{'balance': 1958, 'errors': [[2, 'unknown'], [6, 'duplicate']], 'status': {'A': 'posted', 'B': 'voided', 'D': 'posted', 'R1': 'posted', 'R3': 'reversal'}}{'balance': 1958, 'errors': [[2, 'unknown'], [6, 'duplicate']], 'status': {'A': 'posted', 'B': 'voided', 'D': 'posted', 'R1': 'posted', 'R3': 'reversal'}}Passed

SHA-256 / a7482ef6f2309309a9da4e13d99d311319f6cf5833eb794bc8e4ceed58fdb8e2

3 / The verified repair

Exit 0
"""Failure Map reference implementation. Python standard library only."""
import json

N = 1
observations = []
def solve(x):
    status = {}
    amounts = {}
    errors = []
    for i, cmd in enumerate(x):
        if cmd[0] == 'post':
            _, eid, amt = cmd
            if eid in status:
                errors.append([i, 'duplicate'])
                continue
            status[eid] = 'posted'
            amounts[eid] = amt
        elif cmd[0] == 'void':
            _, target, new = cmd
            if target not in status:
                errors.append([i, 'unknown'])
            elif status[target] != 'posted':
                errors.append([i, 'not_voidable'])
            elif new in status:
                errors.append([i, 'duplicate'])
            else:
                status[target] = 'voided'
                status[new] = 'reversal'
                amounts[new] = -amounts[target]
        else:
            errors.append([i, 'bad_command'])
    return {'status': status, 'balance': sum(amounts.values()), 'errors': errors}
def check(label, actual, expected):
    observations.append({"check": label, "actual": actual, "expected": expected, "passed": actual == expected})
fixtures = [[['regression: failed void side effect', [['post', 'R1', -40], ['post', 'R1', 100], ['post', 'D', 999], ['edit', 'A', 5], ['void', 'R1', 'D'], ['void', 'R1', 'R2'], ['post', 'D', 999], ['void', 'R1', 'R1']], {'status': {'R1': 'voided', 'D': 'posted', 'R2': 'reversal'}, 'balance': 999, 'errors': [[1, 'duplicate'], [3, 'bad_command'], [4, 'duplicate'], [6, 'duplicate'], [7, 'not_voidable']]}], ['control 1', [['edit', 'A', 5], ['post', 'C', 999], ['void', 'C', 'R2'], ['void', 'R3', 'D']], {'status': {'C': 'voided', 'R2': 'reversal'}, 'balance': 0, 'errors': [[0, 'bad_command'], [3, 'unknown']]}], ['control 2', [['post', 'C', 250], ['edit', 'A', 5], ['edit', 'A', 5], ['void', 'R1', 'D']], {'status': {'C': 'posted'}, 'balance': 250, 'errors': [[1, 'bad_command'], [2, 'bad_command'], [3, 'unknown']]}], ['control 3', [['void', 'R2', 'D'], ['post', 'D', 999], ['post', 'D', 999], ['post', 'R1', 100], ['void', 'A', 'D']], {'status': {'D': 'posted', 'R1': 'posted'}, 'balance': 1099, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [2, 'duplicate'], [4, 'unknown']]}], ['control 4', [['void', 'R3', 'R2'], ['void', 'R2', 'D'], ['void', 'R1', 'R2'], ['post', 'D', 250], ['void', 'R2', 'R1'], ['void', 'R1', 'R2'], ['void', 'D', 'R3'], ['post', 'R1', 100]], {'status': {'D': 'voided', 'R3': 'reversal', 'R1': 'posted'}, 'balance': 100, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [2, 'unknown'], [4, 'unknown'], [5, 'unknown']]}], ['control 5', [['void', 'C', 'R1'], ['void', 'R1', 'R2'], ['edit', 'A', 5], ['void', 'C', 'R1'], ['void', 'R3', 'R1'], ['post', 'D', 999]], {'status': {'D': 'posted'}, 'balance': 999, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [2, 'bad_command'], [3, 'unknown'], [4, 'unknown']]}], ['control 6', [['post', 'A', 999], ['post', 'D', -40], ['void', 'R1', 'R1'], ['post', 'B', 999], ['void', 'B', 'R3'], ['post', 'R1', 999], ['post', 'B', 250]], {'status': {'A': 'posted', 'D': 'posted', 'B': 'voided', 'R3': 'reversal', 'R1': 'posted'}, 'balance': 1958, 'errors': [[2, 'unknown'], [6, 'duplicate']]}]], [['regression: failed void side effect', [['post', 'B', 250], ['void', 'D', 'R3'], ['post', 'D', -40], ['post', 'A', -40], ['void', 'R3', 'R1'], ['void', 'R2', 'R3'], ['post', 'R1', -40], ['void', 'B', 'R1']], {'status': {'B': 'posted', 'D': 'posted', 'A': 'posted', 'R1': 'posted'}, 'balance': 130, 'errors': [[1, 'unknown'], [4, 'unknown'], [5, 'unknown'], [7, 'duplicate']]}], ['control 1', [['post', 'B', 250], ['post', 'C', 250], ['edit', 'A', 5], ['post', 'B', 250], ['post', 'B', 100]], {'status': {'B': 'posted', 'C': 'posted'}, 'balance': 500, 'errors': [[2, 'bad_command'], [3, 'duplicate'], [4, 'duplicate']]}], ['control 2', [['post', 'R1', -40], ['post', 'B', 250], ['post', 'C', 250], ['void', 'R2', 'R3']], {'status': {'R1': 'posted', 'B': 'posted', 'C': 'posted'}, 'balance': 460, 'errors': [[3, 'unknown']]}], ['control 3', [['post', 'A', 999], ['void', 'R1', 'R3'], ['void', 'R2', 'R2'], ['post', 'R1', 999]], {'status': {'A': 'posted', 'R1': 'posted'}, 'balance': 1998, 'errors': [[1, 'unknown'], [2, 'unknown']]}], ['control 4', [['void', 'C', 'D'], ['void', 'D', 'R1'], ['void', 'R3', 'D'], ['post', 'A', -40], ['post', 'D', 999], ['post', 'C', -40], ['void', 'R1', 'R3']], {'status': {'A': 'posted', 'D': 'posted', 'C': 'posted'}, 'balance': 919, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [2, 'unknown'], [6, 'unknown']]}], ['control 5', [['void', 'R1', 'R3'], ['void', 'C', 'D'], ['void', 'B', 'D'], ['post', 'R1', 250], ['void', 'R2', 'D'], ['post', 'D', -40], ['void', 'C', 'D']], {'status': {'R1': 'posted', 'D': 'posted'}, 'balance': 210, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [2, 'unknown'], [4, 'unknown'], [6, 'unknown']]}], ['control 6', [['post', 'A', 250], ['post', 'A', 100], ['post', 'D', 999]], {'status': {'A': 'posted', 'D': 'posted'}, 'balance': 1249, 'errors': [[1, 'duplicate']]}]], [['regression: failed void side effect', [['void', 'R3', 'R1'], ['post', 'D', -40], ['void', 'R3', 'R1'], ['post', 'R1', 100], ['post', 'A', 250], ['void', 'R1', 'R3'], ['void', 'A', 'D'], ['void', 'R1', 'R1']], {'status': {'D': 'posted', 'R1': 'voided', 'A': 'posted', 'R3': 'reversal'}, 'balance': 210, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [2, 'unknown'], [6, 'duplicate'], [7, 'not_voidable']]}], ['control 1', [['void', 'R1', 'R3'], ['void', 'A', 'R3'], ['void', 'R3', 'R1']], {'status': {}, 'balance': 0, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [2, 'unknown']]}], ['control 2', [['void', 'C', 'R3'], ['void', 'R1', 'R3'], ['void', 'R2', 'R1'], ['void', 'R1', 'R1'], ['void', 'C', 'D'], ['void', 'A', 'R1'], ['post', 'D', 999]], {'status': {'D': 'posted'}, 'balance': 999, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [2, 'unknown'], [3, 'unknown'], [4, 'unknown'], [5, 'unknown']]}], ['control 3', [['post', 'D', -40], ['void', 'R3', 'R1'], ['post', 'B', 100], ['post', 'R1', 250], ['void', 'C', 'D'], ['post', 'A', 999], ['void', 'R2', 'R2']], {'status': {'D': 'posted', 'B': 'posted', 'R1': 'posted', 'A': 'posted'}, 'balance': 1309, 'errors': [[1, 'unknown'], [4, 'unknown'], [6, 'unknown']]}], ['control 4', [['edit', 'A', 5], ['post', 'R1', -40], ['post', 'C', 100], ['post', 'C', 100], ['post', 'R1', 100], ['void', 'R2', 'D'], ['post', 'B', -40]], {'status': {'R1': 'posted', 'C': 'posted', 'B': 'posted'}, 'balance': 20, 'errors': [[0, 'bad_command'], [3, 'duplicate'], [4, 'duplicate'], [5, 'unknown']]}], ['control 5', [['post', 'C', 250], ['post', 'B', 999], ['void', 'C', 'D'], ['post', 'A', -40], ['void', 'R3', 'R1'], ['void', 'R2', 'R3'], ['void', 'R2', 'R3'], ['void', 'B', 'R1']], {'status': {'C': 'voided', 'B': 'voided', 'D': 'reversal', 'A': 'posted', 'R1': 'reversal'}, 'balance': -40, 'errors': [[4, 'unknown'], [5, 'unknown'], [6, 'unknown']]}], ['control 6', [['post', 'B', 999], ['void', 'R3', 'R1'], ['void', 'D', 'R3'], ['post', 'C', 100], ['post', 'D', 999]], {'status': {'B': 'posted', 'C': 'posted', 'D': 'posted'}, 'balance': 2098, 'errors': [[1, 'unknown'], [2, 'unknown']]}]], [['regression: failed void side effect', [['post', 'C', 999], ['void', 'R2', 'R1'], ['post', 'D', 999], ['post', 'A', 999], ['void', 'D', 'D'], ['post', 'B', -40], ['post', 'B', 999]], {'status': {'C': 'posted', 'D': 'posted', 'A': 'posted', 'B': 'posted'}, 'balance': 2957, 'errors': [[1, 'unknown'], [4, 'duplicate'], [6, 'duplicate']]}], ['control 1', [['void', 'A', 'R1'], ['void', 'A', 'R1'], ['void', 'B', 'R3'], ['post', 'C', 100], ['post', 'B', -40], ['edit', 'A', 5], ['void', 'R2', 'D']], {'status': {'C': 'posted', 'B': 'posted'}, 'balance': 60, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [2, 'unknown'], [5, 'bad_command'], [6, 'unknown']]}], ['control 2', [['void', 'D', 'R1'], ['post', 'D', -40], ['post', 'A', 100], ['void', 'A', 'R1'], ['void', 'A', 'R3']], {'status': {'D': 'posted', 'A': 'voided', 'R1': 'reversal'}, 'balance': -40, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [4, 'not_voidable']]}], ['control 3', [['void', 'D', 'R2'], ['void', 'R3', 'R3'], ['post', 'B', 250], ['void', 'D', 'D'], ['post', 'C', 999], ['post', 'B', -40]], {'status': {'B': 'posted', 'C': 'posted'}, 'balance': 1249, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [3, 'unknown'], [5, 'duplicate']]}], ['control 4', [['post', 'R1', -40], ['void', 'D', 'R1'], ['post', 'A', 250], ['void', 'R1', 'D']], {'status': {'R1': 'voided', 'A': 'posted', 'D': 'reversal'}, 'balance': 250, 'errors': [[1, 'unknown']]}], ['control 5', [['edit', 'A', 5], ['edit', 'A', 5], ['post', 'D', 100], ['post', 'B', 999]], {'status': {'D': 'posted', 'B': 'posted'}, 'balance': 1099, 'errors': [[0, 'bad_command'], [1, 'bad_command']]}], ['control 6', [['post', 'R1', 250], ['void', 'R1', 'D'], ['void', 'R1', 'R3'], ['void', 'R1', 'R3'], ['void', 'D', 'D'], ['post', 'B', -40], ['void', 'B', 'R2'], ['post', 'C', -40]], {'status': {'R1': 'voided', 'D': 'reversal', 'B': 'voided', 'R2': 'reversal', 'C': 'posted'}, 'balance': -40, 'errors': [[2, 'not_voidable'], [3, 'not_voidable'], [4, 'not_voidable']]}]], [['regression: failed void side effect', [['post', 'D', 100], ['void', 'B', 'R3'], ['post', 'A', 999], ['post', 'A', -40], ['void', 'D', 'D'], ['void', 'R1', 'R3']], {'status': {'D': 'posted', 'A': 'posted'}, 'balance': 1099, 'errors': [[1, 'unknown'], [3, 'duplicate'], [4, 'duplicate'], [5, 'unknown']]}], ['control 1', [['void', 'R2', 'R1'], ['void', 'B', 'D'], ['post', 'C', 250]], {'status': {'C': 'posted'}, 'balance': 250, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown']]}], ['control 2', [['void', 'A', 'R1'], ['post', 'A', -40], ['post', 'A', -40], ['post', 'A', 999], ['void', 'R1', 'R2']], {'status': {'A': 'posted'}, 'balance': -40, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [2, 'duplicate'], [3, 'duplicate'], [4, 'unknown']]}], ['control 3', [['post', 'B', 250], ['post', 'D', 100], ['post', 'A', 999], ['post', 'D', -40]], {'status': {'B': 'posted', 'D': 'posted', 'A': 'posted'}, 'balance': 1349, 'errors': [[3, 'duplicate']]}], ['control 4', [['void', 'C', 'R2'], ['void', 'B', 'R3'], ['void', 'R1', 'R2'], ['void', 'D', 'D'], ['void', 'R3', 'R2'], ['post', 'C', 250], ['post', 'A', 999], ['post', 'R1', 100]], {'status': {'C': 'posted', 'A': 'posted', 'R1': 'posted'}, 'balance': 1349, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [2, 'unknown'], [3, 'unknown'], [4, 'unknown']]}], ['control 5', [['void', 'R1', 'R3'], ['post', 'C', 999], ['post', 'R1', -40], ['post', 'D', 999], ['post', 'A', 250], ['post', 'B', 250], ['void', 'R2', 'D']], {'status': {'C': 'posted', 'R1': 'posted', 'D': 'posted', 'A': 'posted', 'B': 'posted'}, 'balance': 2458, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [6, 'unknown']]}], ['control 6', [['void', 'C', 'R1'], ['void', 'R1', 'R1'], ['void', 'R1', 'D'], ['post', 'C', 999], ['void', 'R2', 'D'], ['void', 'R2', 'D'], ['void', 'C', 'R2']], {'status': {'C': 'voided', 'R2': 'reversal'}, 'balance': 0, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [2, 'unknown'], [4, 'unknown'], [5, 'unknown']]}]]]
for label, args, expected in fixtures[N-1]:
    try:
        actual = solve(args)
    except Exception as exc:
        actual = 'raised ' + type(exc).__name__
    check(label, actual, expected)
print(json.dumps({"observations": observations, "passed": all(x["passed"] for x in observations)}, ensure_ascii=False))
raise SystemExit(0 if all(x["passed"] for x in observations) else 1)
Boundary fixtureActualExpectedOutcome
regression: failed void side effect{'balance': 999, 'errors': [[1, 'duplicate'], [3, 'bad_command'], [4, 'duplicate'], [6, 'duplicate'], [7, 'not_voidable']], 'status': {'D': 'posted', 'R1': 'voided', 'R2': 'reversal'}}{'balance': 999, 'errors': [[1, 'duplicate'], [3, 'bad_command'], [4, 'duplicate'], [6, 'duplicate'], [7, 'not_voidable']], 'status': {'D': 'posted', 'R1': 'voided', 'R2': 'reversal'}}Passed
control 1{'balance': 0, 'errors': [[0, 'bad_command'], [3, 'unknown']], 'status': {'C': 'voided', 'R2': 'reversal'}}{'balance': 0, 'errors': [[0, 'bad_command'], [3, 'unknown']], 'status': {'C': 'voided', 'R2': 'reversal'}}Passed
control 2{'balance': 250, 'errors': [[1, 'bad_command'], [2, 'bad_command'], [3, 'unknown']], 'status': {'C': 'posted'}}{'balance': 250, 'errors': [[1, 'bad_command'], [2, 'bad_command'], [3, 'unknown']], 'status': {'C': 'posted'}}Passed
control 3{'balance': 1099, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [2, 'duplicate'], [4, 'unknown']], 'status': {'D': 'posted', 'R1': 'posted'}}{'balance': 1099, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [2, 'duplicate'], [4, 'unknown']], 'status': {'D': 'posted', 'R1': 'posted'}}Passed
control 4{'balance': 100, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [2, 'unknown'], [4, 'unknown'], [5, 'unknown']], 'status': {'D': 'voided', 'R1': 'posted', 'R3': 'reversal'}}{'balance': 100, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [2, 'unknown'], [4, 'unknown'], [5, 'unknown']], 'status': {'D': 'voided', 'R1': 'posted', 'R3': 'reversal'}}Passed
control 5{'balance': 999, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [2, 'bad_command'], [3, 'unknown'], [4, 'unknown']], 'status': {'D': 'posted'}}{'balance': 999, 'errors': [[0, 'unknown'], [1, 'unknown'], [2, 'bad_command'], [3, 'unknown'], [4, 'unknown']], 'status': {'D': 'posted'}}Passed
control 6{'balance': 1958, 'errors': [[2, 'unknown'], [6, 'duplicate']], 'status': {'A': 'posted', 'B': 'voided', 'D': 'posted', 'R1': 'posted', 'R3': 'reversal'}}{'balance': 1958, 'errors': [[2, 'unknown'], [6, 'duplicate']], 'status': {'A': 'posted', 'B': 'voided', 'D': 'posted', 'R1': 'posted', 'R3': 'reversal'}}Passed

SHA-256 / 9551d931a86a06f9f29839557004fd6844f53adfd0c1f0b89d18639e9838b7b3

Verification & scope

A deterministic bounded teaching model with stipulated toy bookkeeping rules stated in the contract; amounts are integer cents; it makes no claim of conformance to any accounting standard or product. This reproducer isolates one failure mechanism. Results cover the supplied fixtures. Variants within a family share a test contract and should remain grouped when constructing evaluation splits. Related mechanisms with a shared evaluation_group must also remain together; these controlled models are not independent production incidents.

Observations recorded using Python 3.12.14 at 2026-09-29T14:46:24.652726+00:00.

Case digest / f8907b63cc2ba96a09e6597525418bc4fd233e05f4b2d727988838c0d73fa825