FAILURE MAP
← Case archive

FA-57271 / Auction allocation rules / Open access

Tie ballot: ticket order commitment · case 01

Ticket-order changes are hidden by set comparison of the published commitment.

Verified by executionVariant 1 · 11 checks per implementationDownload source bundle ↓JSON ↗

ROOT CAUSE

Ticket-order changes are hidden by set comparison of the published commitment.

VERIFIED REPAIR

For ticket order commitment, apply the stipulated decision list(dict.fromkeys(t for t in x["tickets"] if t in x["roster"]))==x["committed"].

Unsuccessful approach: The attempted repair uses True; the explicit regression cases demonstrate that this still violates the stipulated auction rule.

Case contract

A toy tied-award ballot has a frozen eligible bidder roster, published ticket order, one ticket per eligible bidder, and an explicitly supplied draw index. It is deterministic: no randomness claim. Declined winners rotate to the next eligible ticket without returning the declined bidder to the draw. Named decision ticket-order-commitment: For ticket order commitment, apply the stipulated decision list(dict.fromkeys(t for t in x["tickets"] if t in x["roster"]))==x["committed"].

Why this case matters

Offline administrative auction model for software failure analysis.

1 / The failure

Exit 1
"""Failure Map reference implementation. Python standard library only."""
import json

N = 1
observations = []
def solve(x):
    v0 = list(dict.fromkeys(t for t in x["tickets"] if t in x["roster"]))
    v1 = [t for t in x["tickets"] if t in x["roster"]]
    v2 = [t for t in dict.fromkeys(x["tickets"]) if t in x["roster"] and t not in x["disqualified"]]
    v3 = x["roster"][x["draw"]] if 0<=x["draw"]<len(x["roster"]) else None
    v4 = next((t for t in x["committed"] if t not in x["declined"]),None)
    v5 = max(0,x["supply"]-len(set(x["winners"])))
    v6 = set(x["tickets"])&set(x["roster"])==set(x["committed"])
    v7 = x["committed"][:x["supply"]] if x["published"] else []
    v8 = x["round"]==x["ballot_round"]
    v9 = [x["substitutes"].get(w,w) if x["substitutes"].get(w,w) in x["consented"] else w for w in x["winners"]]
    return {'one-ticket-per-bidder':v0,'roster-ticket-admission':v1,'disqualification-before-draw':v2,'draw-index-contract':v3,'declined-ticket-rotation':v4,'ballot-supply-remainder':v5,'ticket-order-commitment':v6,'publication-before-award':v7,'round-specific-ballot':v8,'winner-substitute-consent':v9}
def check(label, actual, expected):
    observations.append({"check": label, "actual": actual, "expected": expected, "passed": actual == expected})
fixtures = [('different ticket commitment', {'roster': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'tickets': ['b', 'a', 'b', 'd', 'c'], 'disqualified': ['c'], 'draw': 1, 'declined': ['b'], 'winners': ['a'], 'supply': 2, 'committed': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'published': True, 'round': 2, 'ballot_round': 1, 'substitutes': {'a': 'z'}, 'consented': ['z']}, [False, False, False, False, False]), ('future ballot / different ticket commitment', {'roster': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'tickets': ['b', 'a', 'b', 'd', 'c'], 'disqualified': ['c'], 'draw': 1, 'declined': ['b'], 'winners': ['a'], 'supply': 2, 'committed': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'published': True, 'round': 2, 'ballot_round': 3, 'substitutes': {'a': 'z'}, 'consented': ['z']}, [False, False, False, False, False]), ('normal contract', {'roster': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'tickets': ['b', 'a', 'b', 'd', 'c'], 'disqualified': ['c'], 'draw': 1, 'declined': ['b'], 'winners': ['a'], 'supply': 2, 'committed': ['b', 'a', 'c'], 'published': True, 'round': 2, 'ballot_round': 1, 'substitutes': {'a': 'z'}, 'consented': ['z']}, [True, True, True, True, True]), ('future ballot', {'roster': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'tickets': ['b', 'a', 'b', 'd', 'c'], 'disqualified': ['c'], 'draw': 1, 'declined': ['b'], 'winners': ['a'], 'supply': 2, 'committed': ['b', 'a', 'c'], 'published': True, 'round': 2, 'ballot_round': 3, 'substitutes': {'a': 'z'}, 'consented': ['z']}, [True, True, True, True, True]), ('no declines', {'roster': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'tickets': ['b', 'a', 'b', 'd', 'c'], 'disqualified': ['c'], 'draw': 1, 'declined': [], 'winners': ['a'], 'supply': 2, 'committed': ['b', 'a', 'c'], 'published': True, 'round': 2, 'ballot_round': 1, 'substitutes': {'a': 'z'}, 'consented': ['z']}, [True, True, True, True, True]), ('draw first', {'roster': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'tickets': ['b', 'a', 'b', 'd', 'c'], 'disqualified': ['c'], 'draw': 0, 'declined': ['b'], 'winners': ['a'], 'supply': 2, 'committed': ['b', 'a', 'c'], 'published': True, 'round': 2, 'ballot_round': 1, 'substitutes': {'a': 'z'}, 'consented': ['z']}, [True, True, True, True, True]), ('draw beyond roster', {'roster': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'tickets': ['b', 'a', 'b', 'd', 'c'], 'disqualified': ['c'], 'draw': 7, 'declined': ['b'], 'winners': ['a'], 'supply': 2, 'committed': ['b', 'a', 'c'], 'published': True, 'round': 2, 'ballot_round': 1, 'substitutes': {'a': 'z'}, 'consented': ['z']}, [True, True, True, True, True]), ('all disqualified', {'roster': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'tickets': ['b', 'a', 'b', 'd', 'c'], 'disqualified': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'draw': 1, 'declined': ['b'], 'winners': ['a'], 'supply': 2, 'committed': ['b', 'a', 'c'], 'published': True, 'round': 2, 'ballot_round': 1, 'substitutes': {'a': 'z'}, 'consented': ['z']}, [True, True, True, True, True]), ('all tickets valid', {'roster': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'tickets': ['b', 'a', 'c'], 'disqualified': ['c'], 'draw': 1, 'declined': ['b'], 'winners': ['a'], 'supply': 2, 'committed': ['b', 'a', 'c'], 'published': True, 'round': 2, 'ballot_round': 1, 'substitutes': {'a': 'z'}, 'consented': ['z']}, [True, True, True, True, True]), ('unpublished draw', {'roster': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'tickets': ['b', 'a', 'b', 'd', 'c'], 'disqualified': ['c'], 'draw': 1, 'declined': ['b'], 'winners': ['a'], 'supply': 2, 'committed': ['b', 'a', 'c'], 'published': False, 'round': 2, 'ballot_round': 1, 'substitutes': {'a': 'z'}, 'consented': ['z']}, [True, True, True, True, True]), ('same round', {'roster': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'tickets': ['b', 'a', 'b', 'd', 'c'], 'disqualified': ['c'], 'draw': 1, 'declined': ['b'], 'winners': ['a'], 'supply': 2, 'committed': ['b', 'a', 'c'], 'published': True, 'round': 2, 'ballot_round': 2, 'substitutes': {'a': 'z'}, 'consented': ['z']}, [True, True, True, True, True])]
def vary(value):
 if type(value) is int: return value*N
 if isinstance(value,list): return [vary(v) for v in value]
 if isinstance(value,dict): return {k:(v if k in ['count', 'delivery_index', 'disputed', 'maximum_set', 'minimum_set', 'stage', 'threshold', 'waived'] else vary(v)) for k,v in value.items()}
 return value
for label, request, expected in fixtures:
 check(label, solve(vary(request))['ticket-order-commitment'], expected[N-1])
print(json.dumps({"observations": observations, "passed": all(x["passed"] for x in observations)}, ensure_ascii=False))
raise SystemExit(0 if all(x["passed"] for x in observations) else 1)
Boundary fixtureActualExpectedOutcome
different ticket commitmentTrueFalseFailed
future ballot / different ticket commitmentTrueFalseFailed
normal contractTrueTruePassed
future ballotTrueTruePassed
no declinesTrueTruePassed
draw firstTrueTruePassed
draw beyond rosterTrueTruePassed
all disqualifiedTrueTruePassed
all tickets validTrueTruePassed
unpublished drawTrueTruePassed
same roundTrueTruePassed

SHA-256 / d2ac329b6964aecef2ece9b6b13678d995d649b8668131096dfea7b00597bfdb

2 / The unsuccessful fix

Exit 1
"""Failure Map reference implementation. Python standard library only."""
import json

N = 1
observations = []
def solve(x):
    v0 = list(dict.fromkeys(t for t in x["tickets"] if t in x["roster"]))
    v1 = [t for t in x["tickets"] if t in x["roster"]]
    v2 = [t for t in dict.fromkeys(x["tickets"]) if t in x["roster"] and t not in x["disqualified"]]
    v3 = x["roster"][x["draw"]] if 0<=x["draw"]<len(x["roster"]) else None
    v4 = next((t for t in x["committed"] if t not in x["declined"]),None)
    v5 = max(0,x["supply"]-len(set(x["winners"])))
    v6 = True
    v7 = x["committed"][:x["supply"]] if x["published"] else []
    v8 = x["round"]==x["ballot_round"]
    v9 = [x["substitutes"].get(w,w) if x["substitutes"].get(w,w) in x["consented"] else w for w in x["winners"]]
    return {'one-ticket-per-bidder':v0,'roster-ticket-admission':v1,'disqualification-before-draw':v2,'draw-index-contract':v3,'declined-ticket-rotation':v4,'ballot-supply-remainder':v5,'ticket-order-commitment':v6,'publication-before-award':v7,'round-specific-ballot':v8,'winner-substitute-consent':v9}
def check(label, actual, expected):
    observations.append({"check": label, "actual": actual, "expected": expected, "passed": actual == expected})
fixtures = [('different ticket commitment', {'roster': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'tickets': ['b', 'a', 'b', 'd', 'c'], 'disqualified': ['c'], 'draw': 1, 'declined': ['b'], 'winners': ['a'], 'supply': 2, 'committed': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'published': True, 'round': 2, 'ballot_round': 1, 'substitutes': {'a': 'z'}, 'consented': ['z']}, [False, False, False, False, False]), ('future ballot / different ticket commitment', {'roster': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'tickets': ['b', 'a', 'b', 'd', 'c'], 'disqualified': ['c'], 'draw': 1, 'declined': ['b'], 'winners': ['a'], 'supply': 2, 'committed': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'published': True, 'round': 2, 'ballot_round': 3, 'substitutes': {'a': 'z'}, 'consented': ['z']}, [False, False, False, False, False]), ('normal contract', {'roster': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'tickets': ['b', 'a', 'b', 'd', 'c'], 'disqualified': ['c'], 'draw': 1, 'declined': ['b'], 'winners': ['a'], 'supply': 2, 'committed': ['b', 'a', 'c'], 'published': True, 'round': 2, 'ballot_round': 1, 'substitutes': {'a': 'z'}, 'consented': ['z']}, [True, True, True, True, True]), ('future ballot', {'roster': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'tickets': ['b', 'a', 'b', 'd', 'c'], 'disqualified': ['c'], 'draw': 1, 'declined': ['b'], 'winners': ['a'], 'supply': 2, 'committed': ['b', 'a', 'c'], 'published': True, 'round': 2, 'ballot_round': 3, 'substitutes': {'a': 'z'}, 'consented': ['z']}, [True, True, True, True, True]), ('no declines', {'roster': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'tickets': ['b', 'a', 'b', 'd', 'c'], 'disqualified': ['c'], 'draw': 1, 'declined': [], 'winners': ['a'], 'supply': 2, 'committed': ['b', 'a', 'c'], 'published': True, 'round': 2, 'ballot_round': 1, 'substitutes': {'a': 'z'}, 'consented': ['z']}, [True, True, True, True, True]), ('draw first', {'roster': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'tickets': ['b', 'a', 'b', 'd', 'c'], 'disqualified': ['c'], 'draw': 0, 'declined': ['b'], 'winners': ['a'], 'supply': 2, 'committed': ['b', 'a', 'c'], 'published': True, 'round': 2, 'ballot_round': 1, 'substitutes': {'a': 'z'}, 'consented': ['z']}, [True, True, True, True, True]), ('draw beyond roster', {'roster': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'tickets': ['b', 'a', 'b', 'd', 'c'], 'disqualified': ['c'], 'draw': 7, 'declined': ['b'], 'winners': ['a'], 'supply': 2, 'committed': ['b', 'a', 'c'], 'published': True, 'round': 2, 'ballot_round': 1, 'substitutes': {'a': 'z'}, 'consented': ['z']}, [True, True, True, True, True]), ('all disqualified', {'roster': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'tickets': ['b', 'a', 'b', 'd', 'c'], 'disqualified': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'draw': 1, 'declined': ['b'], 'winners': ['a'], 'supply': 2, 'committed': ['b', 'a', 'c'], 'published': True, 'round': 2, 'ballot_round': 1, 'substitutes': {'a': 'z'}, 'consented': ['z']}, [True, True, True, True, True]), ('all tickets valid', {'roster': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'tickets': ['b', 'a', 'c'], 'disqualified': ['c'], 'draw': 1, 'declined': ['b'], 'winners': ['a'], 'supply': 2, 'committed': ['b', 'a', 'c'], 'published': True, 'round': 2, 'ballot_round': 1, 'substitutes': {'a': 'z'}, 'consented': ['z']}, [True, True, True, True, True]), ('unpublished draw', {'roster': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'tickets': ['b', 'a', 'b', 'd', 'c'], 'disqualified': ['c'], 'draw': 1, 'declined': ['b'], 'winners': ['a'], 'supply': 2, 'committed': ['b', 'a', 'c'], 'published': False, 'round': 2, 'ballot_round': 1, 'substitutes': {'a': 'z'}, 'consented': ['z']}, [True, True, True, True, True]), ('same round', {'roster': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'tickets': ['b', 'a', 'b', 'd', 'c'], 'disqualified': ['c'], 'draw': 1, 'declined': ['b'], 'winners': ['a'], 'supply': 2, 'committed': ['b', 'a', 'c'], 'published': True, 'round': 2, 'ballot_round': 2, 'substitutes': {'a': 'z'}, 'consented': ['z']}, [True, True, True, True, True])]
def vary(value):
 if type(value) is int: return value*N
 if isinstance(value,list): return [vary(v) for v in value]
 if isinstance(value,dict): return {k:(v if k in ['count', 'delivery_index', 'disputed', 'maximum_set', 'minimum_set', 'stage', 'threshold', 'waived'] else vary(v)) for k,v in value.items()}
 return value
for label, request, expected in fixtures:
 check(label, solve(vary(request))['ticket-order-commitment'], expected[N-1])
print(json.dumps({"observations": observations, "passed": all(x["passed"] for x in observations)}, ensure_ascii=False))
raise SystemExit(0 if all(x["passed"] for x in observations) else 1)
Boundary fixtureActualExpectedOutcome
different ticket commitmentTrueFalseFailed
future ballot / different ticket commitmentTrueFalseFailed
normal contractTrueTruePassed
future ballotTrueTruePassed
no declinesTrueTruePassed
draw firstTrueTruePassed
draw beyond rosterTrueTruePassed
all disqualifiedTrueTruePassed
all tickets validTrueTruePassed
unpublished drawTrueTruePassed
same roundTrueTruePassed

SHA-256 / 5ae59dabf9d10d2db36e65c8de1aabfb1eb2d346fd5659144b5117cfd9c76909

3 / The verified repair

Exit 0
"""Failure Map reference implementation. Python standard library only."""
import json

N = 1
observations = []
def solve(x):
    v0 = list(dict.fromkeys(t for t in x["tickets"] if t in x["roster"]))
    v1 = [t for t in x["tickets"] if t in x["roster"]]
    v2 = [t for t in dict.fromkeys(x["tickets"]) if t in x["roster"] and t not in x["disqualified"]]
    v3 = x["roster"][x["draw"]] if 0<=x["draw"]<len(x["roster"]) else None
    v4 = next((t for t in x["committed"] if t not in x["declined"]),None)
    v5 = max(0,x["supply"]-len(set(x["winners"])))
    v6 = list(dict.fromkeys(t for t in x["tickets"] if t in x["roster"]))==x["committed"]
    v7 = x["committed"][:x["supply"]] if x["published"] else []
    v8 = x["round"]==x["ballot_round"]
    v9 = [x["substitutes"].get(w,w) if x["substitutes"].get(w,w) in x["consented"] else w for w in x["winners"]]
    return {'one-ticket-per-bidder':v0,'roster-ticket-admission':v1,'disqualification-before-draw':v2,'draw-index-contract':v3,'declined-ticket-rotation':v4,'ballot-supply-remainder':v5,'ticket-order-commitment':v6,'publication-before-award':v7,'round-specific-ballot':v8,'winner-substitute-consent':v9}
def check(label, actual, expected):
    observations.append({"check": label, "actual": actual, "expected": expected, "passed": actual == expected})
fixtures = [('different ticket commitment', {'roster': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'tickets': ['b', 'a', 'b', 'd', 'c'], 'disqualified': ['c'], 'draw': 1, 'declined': ['b'], 'winners': ['a'], 'supply': 2, 'committed': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'published': True, 'round': 2, 'ballot_round': 1, 'substitutes': {'a': 'z'}, 'consented': ['z']}, [False, False, False, False, False]), ('future ballot / different ticket commitment', {'roster': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'tickets': ['b', 'a', 'b', 'd', 'c'], 'disqualified': ['c'], 'draw': 1, 'declined': ['b'], 'winners': ['a'], 'supply': 2, 'committed': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'published': True, 'round': 2, 'ballot_round': 3, 'substitutes': {'a': 'z'}, 'consented': ['z']}, [False, False, False, False, False]), ('normal contract', {'roster': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'tickets': ['b', 'a', 'b', 'd', 'c'], 'disqualified': ['c'], 'draw': 1, 'declined': ['b'], 'winners': ['a'], 'supply': 2, 'committed': ['b', 'a', 'c'], 'published': True, 'round': 2, 'ballot_round': 1, 'substitutes': {'a': 'z'}, 'consented': ['z']}, [True, True, True, True, True]), ('future ballot', {'roster': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'tickets': ['b', 'a', 'b', 'd', 'c'], 'disqualified': ['c'], 'draw': 1, 'declined': ['b'], 'winners': ['a'], 'supply': 2, 'committed': ['b', 'a', 'c'], 'published': True, 'round': 2, 'ballot_round': 3, 'substitutes': {'a': 'z'}, 'consented': ['z']}, [True, True, True, True, True]), ('no declines', {'roster': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'tickets': ['b', 'a', 'b', 'd', 'c'], 'disqualified': ['c'], 'draw': 1, 'declined': [], 'winners': ['a'], 'supply': 2, 'committed': ['b', 'a', 'c'], 'published': True, 'round': 2, 'ballot_round': 1, 'substitutes': {'a': 'z'}, 'consented': ['z']}, [True, True, True, True, True]), ('draw first', {'roster': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'tickets': ['b', 'a', 'b', 'd', 'c'], 'disqualified': ['c'], 'draw': 0, 'declined': ['b'], 'winners': ['a'], 'supply': 2, 'committed': ['b', 'a', 'c'], 'published': True, 'round': 2, 'ballot_round': 1, 'substitutes': {'a': 'z'}, 'consented': ['z']}, [True, True, True, True, True]), ('draw beyond roster', {'roster': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'tickets': ['b', 'a', 'b', 'd', 'c'], 'disqualified': ['c'], 'draw': 7, 'declined': ['b'], 'winners': ['a'], 'supply': 2, 'committed': ['b', 'a', 'c'], 'published': True, 'round': 2, 'ballot_round': 1, 'substitutes': {'a': 'z'}, 'consented': ['z']}, [True, True, True, True, True]), ('all disqualified', {'roster': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'tickets': ['b', 'a', 'b', 'd', 'c'], 'disqualified': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'draw': 1, 'declined': ['b'], 'winners': ['a'], 'supply': 2, 'committed': ['b', 'a', 'c'], 'published': True, 'round': 2, 'ballot_round': 1, 'substitutes': {'a': 'z'}, 'consented': ['z']}, [True, True, True, True, True]), ('all tickets valid', {'roster': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'tickets': ['b', 'a', 'c'], 'disqualified': ['c'], 'draw': 1, 'declined': ['b'], 'winners': ['a'], 'supply': 2, 'committed': ['b', 'a', 'c'], 'published': True, 'round': 2, 'ballot_round': 1, 'substitutes': {'a': 'z'}, 'consented': ['z']}, [True, True, True, True, True]), ('unpublished draw', {'roster': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'tickets': ['b', 'a', 'b', 'd', 'c'], 'disqualified': ['c'], 'draw': 1, 'declined': ['b'], 'winners': ['a'], 'supply': 2, 'committed': ['b', 'a', 'c'], 'published': False, 'round': 2, 'ballot_round': 1, 'substitutes': {'a': 'z'}, 'consented': ['z']}, [True, True, True, True, True]), ('same round', {'roster': ['a', 'b', 'c'], 'tickets': ['b', 'a', 'b', 'd', 'c'], 'disqualified': ['c'], 'draw': 1, 'declined': ['b'], 'winners': ['a'], 'supply': 2, 'committed': ['b', 'a', 'c'], 'published': True, 'round': 2, 'ballot_round': 2, 'substitutes': {'a': 'z'}, 'consented': ['z']}, [True, True, True, True, True])]
def vary(value):
 if type(value) is int: return value*N
 if isinstance(value,list): return [vary(v) for v in value]
 if isinstance(value,dict): return {k:(v if k in ['count', 'delivery_index', 'disputed', 'maximum_set', 'minimum_set', 'stage', 'threshold', 'waived'] else vary(v)) for k,v in value.items()}
 return value
for label, request, expected in fixtures:
 check(label, solve(vary(request))['ticket-order-commitment'], expected[N-1])
print(json.dumps({"observations": observations, "passed": all(x["passed"] for x in observations)}, ensure_ascii=False))
raise SystemExit(0 if all(x["passed"] for x in observations) else 1)
Boundary fixtureActualExpectedOutcome
different ticket commitmentFalseFalsePassed
future ballot / different ticket commitmentFalseFalsePassed
normal contractTrueTruePassed
future ballotTrueTruePassed
no declinesTrueTruePassed
draw firstTrueTruePassed
draw beyond rosterTrueTruePassed
all disqualifiedTrueTruePassed
all tickets validTrueTruePassed
unpublished drawTrueTruePassed
same roundTrueTruePassed

SHA-256 / b8a3bfef61d9fa0197e016e550282cac274df00383e3fc3c2dc94de579f9f096

Verification & scope

Stipulated toy auction rules, not a venue specification, financial advice, optimization claim, or live trading implementation. Nonnegative integer inputs and internally aligned list fields only. This reproducer isolates one failure mechanism. Results cover the supplied fixtures. Variants within a family share a test contract and should remain grouped when constructing evaluation splits. Related mechanisms with a shared evaluation_group must also remain together; these controlled models are not independent production incidents.

Observations recorded using Python 3.12.14 at 2026-09-29T14:46:15.054740+00:00.

Case digest / d1cc88325ed5bf9b1fa964e5d8b4d35384e8f0ef3fe4601cd01343a93605a9d6