{"abstract":"Explicit clearing transfers ownership away from defaults is violated by the widget projection.","category":"Filter interfaces","checks":10,"contract":"Default filters are applied only before user intent exists; an explicit cleared state differs from absence, and changes to defaults do not overwrite user-owned settings. This example checks: Explicit clearing transfers ownership away from defaults.","contract_signature":"d","evaluation_group":"s3-filter-interfaces-default-provenance","failed_approach":"The attempted correction `'default'` still violates the explicit contract fixtures.","family":"s3-filter-interfaces-default-provenance-clear-origin","id":"FA-25661","implementations":{"attempt":{"sha256":"e004364d236aa2b293aefafb2ff067eda97204948279fe59bada0cff711b6df9","source":"\"\"\"Failure Map reference implementation. Python standard library only.\"\"\"\nimport json\n\nN = 1\nobservations = []\ndef solve(d):\n    return {'initial-default':(d['user'] if d['present'] else d['default']), 'default-update':(d['new_default'] if d['origin']=='default' else d['user']), 'clear-origin':('default'), 'reset-to-default':(list(d['new_default'])), 'default-badge':(d['origin']=='default'), 'persist-empty':(d['present'] and d['user']==[])}\ndef check(label, actual, expected):\n    observations.append({\"check\": label, \"actual\": actual, \"expected\": expected, \"passed\": actual == expected})\nfixtures = {1: [({'user': [], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': [], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': [], 'default-update': [], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': True}), ({'user': ['a'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['a'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['b'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['b'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['b'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['b'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['b'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['b'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['b'], 'default-update': ['b'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': [], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': [], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': [], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': [], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': True}), ({'user': ['a'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False})], 2: [({'user': [], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': [], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': True}), ({'user': ['a'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': [], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': [], 'default-update': [], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': True}), ({'user': ['a'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['a'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['a'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['a'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['a'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['b'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['b'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['b'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['b'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['b'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['b'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['b'], 'default-update': ['b'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False})], 3: [({'user': ['a'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['b'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['b'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['b'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['b'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['b'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['b'], 'default-update': ['b'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': [], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': [], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': [], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': [], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': [], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': True}), ({'user': [], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': [], 'default-update': [], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': True}), ({'user': ['a'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['a'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['a'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False})], 4: [({'user': ['a'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': [], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['a'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['a'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['a'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['a'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['a'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['b'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['b'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['b'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['b'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['b'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['b'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['b'], 'default-update': ['b'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': [], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': [], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False})], 5: [({'user': ['b'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': [], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': [], 'default-update': [], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': True}), ({'user': ['b'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['b'], 'default-update': ['b'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': [], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': [], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': [], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': [], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': [], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': True}), ({'user': ['a'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['a'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['a'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['a'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['a'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['a'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False})]}\nfor index, (data, expected) in enumerate(fixtures[N]):\n    check(\"contract fixture \" + str(index), solve(data), expected)\nprint(json.dumps({\"observations\": observations, \"passed\": all(x[\"passed\"] for x in observations)}, ensure_ascii=False))\nraise SystemExit(0 if all(x[\"passed\"] for x in observations) else 1)\n"},"broken":{"sha256":"ff25d1bec350c360124d8cd82afc58e9d439841f06edfb967df06fa0abbc81e1","source":"\"\"\"Failure Map reference implementation. Python standard library only.\"\"\"\nimport json\n\nN = 1\nobservations = []\ndef solve(d):\n    return {'initial-default':(d['user'] if d['present'] else d['default']), 'default-update':(d['new_default'] if d['origin']=='default' else d['user']), 'clear-origin':(d['origin']), 'reset-to-default':(list(d['new_default'])), 'default-badge':(d['origin']=='default'), 'persist-empty':(d['present'] and d['user']==[])}\ndef check(label, actual, expected):\n    observations.append({\"check\": label, \"actual\": actual, \"expected\": expected, \"passed\": actual == expected})\nfixtures = {1: [({'user': [], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': [], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': [], 'default-update': [], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': True}), ({'user': ['a'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['a'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['b'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['b'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['b'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['b'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['b'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['b'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['b'], 'default-update': ['b'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': [], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': [], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': [], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': [], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': True}), ({'user': ['a'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False})], 2: [({'user': [], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': [], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': True}), ({'user': ['a'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': [], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': [], 'default-update': [], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': True}), ({'user': ['a'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['a'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['a'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['a'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['a'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['b'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['b'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['b'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['b'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['b'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['b'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['b'], 'default-update': ['b'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False})], 3: [({'user': ['a'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['b'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['b'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['b'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['b'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['b'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['b'], 'default-update': ['b'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': [], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': [], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': [], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': [], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': [], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': True}), ({'user': [], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': [], 'default-update': [], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': True}), ({'user': ['a'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['a'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['a'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False})], 4: [({'user': ['a'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': [], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['a'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['a'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['a'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['a'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['a'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['b'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['b'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['b'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['b'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['b'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['b'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['b'], 'default-update': ['b'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': [], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': [], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False})], 5: [({'user': ['b'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': [], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': [], 'default-update': [], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': True}), ({'user': ['b'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['b'], 'default-update': ['b'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': [], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': [], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': [], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': [], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': [], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': True}), ({'user': ['a'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['a'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': False, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['a'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['a'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'default'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['c'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': True, 'persist-empty': False}), ({'user': ['a'], 'default': ['a'], 'new_default': ['c'], 'present': True, 'origin': 'user'}, {'initial-default': ['a'], 'default-update': ['a'], 'clear-origin': 'user', 'reset-to-default': ['c'], 'default-badge': False, 'persist-empty': False})]}\nfor index, (data, expected) in enumerate(fixtures[N]):\n    check(\"contract fixture \" + str(index), solve(data), expected)\nprint(json.dumps({\"observations\": observations, \"passed\": all(x[\"passed\"] for x in observations)}, ensure_ascii=False))\nraise SystemExit(0 if all(x[\"passed\"] for x in observations) else 1)\n"}},"limitations":"Deterministic bounded UI-state model only; no browser, query engine, network, or production-standard conformance is claimed. This reproducer isolates one failure mechanism. Results cover the supplied fixtures. Variants within a family share a test contract and should remain grouped when constructing evaluation splits. Related mechanisms with a shared evaluation_group must also remain together; these controlled models are not independent production incidents.","method":"Deterministic executable model with adversarial boundary fixtures.","provenance":{"created_by":"Failure Map","dependencies":"Python standard library","family":"s3-filter-interfaces-default-provenance-clear-origin","generated_at":"2026-09-29T14:41:08.707227+00:00","license":"CC0-1.0","python":"3.12.14","seed":1,"split":"open-access"},"relevance":"Filter-widget state and serialization must preserve user constraints while the view changes.","root_cause":"The clear-origin decision uses `d['origin']` instead of the stipulated default-provenance projection.","sha256":"a97f64035ac363b65fa3f02e611861601c7e6f9732c2b3009bc09a0825cf2c66","title":"Explicit clearing transfers ownership away from defaults · case 01","variant":1,"variant_policy":"Five numbered records share a model and may reuse boundary fixtures.","verified":true,"visibility":"public","verification":{"attempt":{"elapsed_ms":40.787,"exit_code":1,"observations":[{"actual":{"clear-origin":"default","default-badge":true,"default-update":["c"],"initial-default":["a"],"persist-empty":false,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"check":"contract fixture 0","expected":{"clear-origin":"user","default-badge":true,"default-update":["c"],"initial-default":["a"],"persist-empty":false,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"passed":false},{"actual":{"clear-origin":"default","default-badge":false,"default-update":[],"initial-default":[],"persist-empty":true,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"check":"contract fixture 1","expected":{"clear-origin":"user","default-badge":false,"default-update":[],"initial-default":[],"persist-empty":true,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"passed":false},{"actual":{"clear-origin":"default","default-badge":false,"default-update":["a"],"initial-default":["a"],"persist-empty":false,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"check":"contract fixture 2","expected":{"clear-origin":"user","default-badge":false,"default-update":["a"],"initial-default":["a"],"persist-empty":false,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"passed":false},{"actual":{"clear-origin":"default","default-badge":true,"default-update":["c"],"initial-default":["a"],"persist-empty":false,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"check":"contract fixture 3","expected":{"clear-origin":"user","default-badge":true,"default-update":["c"],"initial-default":["a"],"persist-empty":false,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"passed":false},{"actual":{"clear-origin":"default","default-badge":false,"default-update":["b"],"initial-default":["a"],"persist-empty":false,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"check":"contract fixture 4","expected":{"clear-origin":"user","default-badge":false,"default-update":["b"],"initial-default":["a"],"persist-empty":false,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"passed":false},{"actual":{"clear-origin":"default","default-badge":true,"default-update":["c"],"initial-default":["b"],"persist-empty":false,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"check":"contract fixture 5","expected":{"clear-origin":"user","default-badge":true,"default-update":["c"],"initial-default":["b"],"persist-empty":false,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"passed":false},{"actual":{"clear-origin":"default","default-badge":false,"default-update":["b"],"initial-default":["b"],"persist-empty":false,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"check":"contract fixture 6","expected":{"clear-origin":"user","default-badge":false,"default-update":["b"],"initial-default":["b"],"persist-empty":false,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"passed":false},{"actual":{"clear-origin":"default","default-badge":false,"default-update":[],"initial-default":["a"],"persist-empty":false,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"check":"contract fixture 7","expected":{"clear-origin":"user","default-badge":false,"default-update":[],"initial-default":["a"],"persist-empty":false,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"passed":false},{"actual":{"clear-origin":"default","default-badge":true,"default-update":["c"],"initial-default":[],"persist-empty":true,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"check":"contract fixture 8","expected":{"clear-origin":"user","default-badge":true,"default-update":["c"],"initial-default":[],"persist-empty":true,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"passed":false},{"actual":{"clear-origin":"default","default-badge":true,"default-update":["c"],"initial-default":["a"],"persist-empty":false,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"check":"contract fixture 9","expected":{"clear-origin":"user","default-badge":true,"default-update":["c"],"initial-default":["a"],"persist-empty":false,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"passed":false}],"passed":false,"stderr":"","stdout":"{\"observations\": [{\"check\": \"contract fixture 0\", \"actual\": {\"initial-default\": [\"a\"], \"default-update\": [\"c\"], \"clear-origin\": \"default\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": true, \"persist-empty\": false}, \"expected\": {\"initial-default\": [\"a\"], \"default-update\": [\"c\"], \"clear-origin\": \"user\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": true, \"persist-empty\": false}, \"passed\": false}, {\"check\": \"contract fixture 1\", \"actual\": {\"initial-default\": [], \"default-update\": [], \"clear-origin\": \"default\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": false, \"persist-empty\": true}, \"expected\": {\"initial-default\": [], \"default-update\": [], \"clear-origin\": \"user\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": false, \"persist-empty\": true}, \"passed\": false}, {\"check\": \"contract fixture 2\", \"actual\": {\"initial-default\": [\"a\"], \"default-update\": [\"a\"], \"clear-origin\": \"default\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": false, \"persist-empty\": false}, \"expected\": {\"initial-default\": [\"a\"], \"default-update\": [\"a\"], \"clear-origin\": \"user\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": false, \"persist-empty\": false}, \"passed\": false}, {\"check\": \"contract fixture 3\", \"actual\": {\"initial-default\": [\"a\"], \"default-update\": [\"c\"], \"clear-origin\": \"default\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": true, \"persist-empty\": false}, \"expected\": {\"initial-default\": [\"a\"], \"default-update\": [\"c\"], \"clear-origin\": \"user\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": true, \"persist-empty\": false}, \"passed\": false}, {\"check\": \"contract fixture 4\", \"actual\": {\"initial-default\": [\"a\"], \"default-update\": [\"b\"], \"clear-origin\": \"default\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": false, \"persist-empty\": false}, \"expected\": {\"initial-default\": [\"a\"], \"default-update\": [\"b\"], \"clear-origin\": \"user\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": false, \"persist-empty\": false}, \"passed\": false}, {\"check\": \"contract fixture 5\", \"actual\": {\"initial-default\": [\"b\"], \"default-update\": [\"c\"], \"clear-origin\": \"default\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": true, \"persist-empty\": false}, \"expected\": {\"initial-default\": [\"b\"], \"default-update\": [\"c\"], \"clear-origin\": \"user\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": true, \"persist-empty\": false}, \"passed\": false}, {\"check\": \"contract fixture 6\", \"actual\": {\"initial-default\": [\"b\"], \"default-update\": [\"b\"], \"clear-origin\": \"default\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": false, \"persist-empty\": false}, \"expected\": {\"initial-default\": [\"b\"], \"default-update\": [\"b\"], \"clear-origin\": \"user\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": false, \"persist-empty\": false}, \"passed\": false}, {\"check\": \"contract fixture 7\", \"actual\": {\"initial-default\": [\"a\"], \"default-update\": [], \"clear-origin\": \"default\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": false, \"persist-empty\": false}, \"expected\": {\"initial-default\": [\"a\"], \"default-update\": [], \"clear-origin\": \"user\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": false, \"persist-empty\": false}, \"passed\": false}, {\"check\": \"contract fixture 8\", \"actual\": {\"initial-default\": [], \"default-update\": [\"c\"], \"clear-origin\": \"default\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": true, \"persist-empty\": true}, \"expected\": {\"initial-default\": [], \"default-update\": [\"c\"], \"clear-origin\": \"user\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": true, \"persist-empty\": true}, \"passed\": false}, {\"check\": \"contract fixture 9\", \"actual\": {\"initial-default\": [\"a\"], \"default-update\": [\"c\"], \"clear-origin\": \"default\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": true, \"persist-empty\": false}, \"expected\": {\"initial-default\": [\"a\"], \"default-update\": [\"c\"], \"clear-origin\": \"user\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": true, \"persist-empty\": false}, \"passed\": false}], \"passed\": false}\n"},"broken":{"elapsed_ms":42.661,"exit_code":1,"observations":[{"actual":{"clear-origin":"default","default-badge":true,"default-update":["c"],"initial-default":["a"],"persist-empty":false,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"check":"contract fixture 0","expected":{"clear-origin":"user","default-badge":true,"default-update":["c"],"initial-default":["a"],"persist-empty":false,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"passed":false},{"actual":{"clear-origin":"user","default-badge":false,"default-update":[],"initial-default":[],"persist-empty":true,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"check":"contract fixture 1","expected":{"clear-origin":"user","default-badge":false,"default-update":[],"initial-default":[],"persist-empty":true,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"passed":true},{"actual":{"clear-origin":"user","default-badge":false,"default-update":["a"],"initial-default":["a"],"persist-empty":false,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"check":"contract fixture 2","expected":{"clear-origin":"user","default-badge":false,"default-update":["a"],"initial-default":["a"],"persist-empty":false,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"passed":true},{"actual":{"clear-origin":"default","default-badge":true,"default-update":["c"],"initial-default":["a"],"persist-empty":false,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"check":"contract fixture 3","expected":{"clear-origin":"user","default-badge":true,"default-update":["c"],"initial-default":["a"],"persist-empty":false,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"passed":false},{"actual":{"clear-origin":"user","default-badge":false,"default-update":["b"],"initial-default":["a"],"persist-empty":false,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"check":"contract fixture 4","expected":{"clear-origin":"user","default-badge":false,"default-update":["b"],"initial-default":["a"],"persist-empty":false,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"passed":true},{"actual":{"clear-origin":"default","default-badge":true,"default-update":["c"],"initial-default":["b"],"persist-empty":false,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"check":"contract fixture 5","expected":{"clear-origin":"user","default-badge":true,"default-update":["c"],"initial-default":["b"],"persist-empty":false,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"passed":false},{"actual":{"clear-origin":"user","default-badge":false,"default-update":["b"],"initial-default":["b"],"persist-empty":false,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"check":"contract fixture 6","expected":{"clear-origin":"user","default-badge":false,"default-update":["b"],"initial-default":["b"],"persist-empty":false,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"passed":true},{"actual":{"clear-origin":"user","default-badge":false,"default-update":[],"initial-default":["a"],"persist-empty":false,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"check":"contract fixture 7","expected":{"clear-origin":"user","default-badge":false,"default-update":[],"initial-default":["a"],"persist-empty":false,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"passed":true},{"actual":{"clear-origin":"default","default-badge":true,"default-update":["c"],"initial-default":[],"persist-empty":true,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"check":"contract fixture 8","expected":{"clear-origin":"user","default-badge":true,"default-update":["c"],"initial-default":[],"persist-empty":true,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"passed":false},{"actual":{"clear-origin":"default","default-badge":true,"default-update":["c"],"initial-default":["a"],"persist-empty":false,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"check":"contract fixture 9","expected":{"clear-origin":"user","default-badge":true,"default-update":["c"],"initial-default":["a"],"persist-empty":false,"reset-to-default":["c"]},"passed":false}],"passed":false,"stderr":"","stdout":"{\"observations\": [{\"check\": \"contract fixture 0\", \"actual\": {\"initial-default\": [\"a\"], \"default-update\": [\"c\"], \"clear-origin\": \"default\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": true, \"persist-empty\": false}, \"expected\": {\"initial-default\": [\"a\"], \"default-update\": [\"c\"], \"clear-origin\": \"user\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": true, \"persist-empty\": false}, \"passed\": false}, {\"check\": \"contract fixture 1\", \"actual\": {\"initial-default\": [], \"default-update\": [], \"clear-origin\": \"user\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": false, \"persist-empty\": true}, \"expected\": {\"initial-default\": [], \"default-update\": [], \"clear-origin\": \"user\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": false, \"persist-empty\": true}, \"passed\": true}, {\"check\": \"contract fixture 2\", \"actual\": {\"initial-default\": [\"a\"], \"default-update\": [\"a\"], \"clear-origin\": \"user\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": false, \"persist-empty\": false}, \"expected\": {\"initial-default\": [\"a\"], \"default-update\": [\"a\"], \"clear-origin\": \"user\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": false, \"persist-empty\": false}, \"passed\": true}, {\"check\": \"contract fixture 3\", \"actual\": {\"initial-default\": [\"a\"], \"default-update\": [\"c\"], \"clear-origin\": \"default\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": true, \"persist-empty\": false}, \"expected\": {\"initial-default\": [\"a\"], \"default-update\": [\"c\"], \"clear-origin\": \"user\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": true, \"persist-empty\": false}, \"passed\": false}, {\"check\": \"contract fixture 4\", \"actual\": {\"initial-default\": [\"a\"], \"default-update\": [\"b\"], \"clear-origin\": \"user\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": false, \"persist-empty\": false}, \"expected\": {\"initial-default\": [\"a\"], \"default-update\": [\"b\"], \"clear-origin\": \"user\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": false, \"persist-empty\": false}, \"passed\": true}, {\"check\": \"contract fixture 5\", \"actual\": {\"initial-default\": [\"b\"], \"default-update\": [\"c\"], \"clear-origin\": \"default\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": true, \"persist-empty\": false}, \"expected\": {\"initial-default\": [\"b\"], \"default-update\": [\"c\"], \"clear-origin\": \"user\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": true, \"persist-empty\": false}, \"passed\": false}, {\"check\": \"contract fixture 6\", \"actual\": {\"initial-default\": [\"b\"], \"default-update\": [\"b\"], \"clear-origin\": \"user\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": false, \"persist-empty\": false}, \"expected\": {\"initial-default\": [\"b\"], \"default-update\": [\"b\"], \"clear-origin\": \"user\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": false, \"persist-empty\": false}, \"passed\": true}, {\"check\": \"contract fixture 7\", \"actual\": {\"initial-default\": [\"a\"], \"default-update\": [], \"clear-origin\": \"user\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": false, \"persist-empty\": false}, \"expected\": {\"initial-default\": [\"a\"], \"default-update\": [], \"clear-origin\": \"user\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": false, \"persist-empty\": false}, \"passed\": true}, {\"check\": \"contract fixture 8\", \"actual\": {\"initial-default\": [], \"default-update\": [\"c\"], \"clear-origin\": \"default\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": true, \"persist-empty\": true}, \"expected\": {\"initial-default\": [], \"default-update\": [\"c\"], \"clear-origin\": \"user\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": true, \"persist-empty\": true}, \"passed\": false}, {\"check\": \"contract fixture 9\", \"actual\": {\"initial-default\": [\"a\"], \"default-update\": [\"c\"], \"clear-origin\": \"default\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": true, \"persist-empty\": false}, \"expected\": {\"initial-default\": [\"a\"], \"default-update\": [\"c\"], \"clear-origin\": \"user\", \"reset-to-default\": [\"c\"], \"default-badge\": true, \"persist-empty\": false}, \"passed\": false}], \"passed\": false}\n"}},"member_only":{"stages":["fixed"],"fields":["implementations.fixed","verification.fixed","harness","repair"],"note":"The verified repair, its recorded checks, the repair description, and the scoring harness are available to members."}}